Worked at the PFX tour this weekend - Part I: The Bad

[tcblue13]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Same in softball and I abhor the practice. The reason offered for this was to get the umpire out of the path of defenders leaving the field to reduce possible confrontations. Bull$hit!

I would rather have the ability to talk to my partner without announcing it to the world. Things happen and occasionally change during a ball game. I may see something my partner is not and vice versa. Maybe one of you want to remind your partner of a proper mechanic or position.

Such communication is even more important if working with someone who may be relatively new to umpiring or the level or rules of the game being worked.

I totally agree. There have been time when a partner has helped me to understand rules or to get in better position through a between inning discussion. There have been times when I have helped a partner make an adjustment or understand a call I made.
Last season, our booker told us to cease the mid inning chats especially after any controversial calls. I know, that is redundant for if you cease to chat, you cease to chat in all situations. I guess his point was that coaches would think that you were unsure of a call if you discussed it between innings.