Four Balls and One Strike

[Bluefoot]

I thought we were taught to say the following, and I also remember this being in the Umpires' Conduct section of rule books and umpire manuals:

"Ball."
"Ball."
"Ball."
"Ball four."

[Mountaineer]

Would you also allow the batter to step back in having just swung at strike three? i simply call all 4 balls the same and like you only differ on the third stike looking. However, if the batter doesn't move in the correct direction - I'll say (just loud enough for the batter and catcher to hear) "that's three" or "that's four" and they take off.

[NC_Blue]

Would you also allow the batter to step back in having just swung at strike three?

Heck yeah! It's more fun to laugh at 'em!

Just kidding. "Ball Four".

[Skahtboi]

I don't do anything differently than Steve mentioned. However, on the fourth ball, I do remove my mask and step out from behind the catcher to watch the runner advance. This should clue them in as to what they should be doing at that time.

[AtlUmpSteve]

I think the key here that we might want to impart to those who are unsure, is that we cannot ignore either strike three nor ball four. Despite mechanics that now tell us to NOT coach, not tell them where first base is, not announce "four", etc., our choices do not include allow another pitch to be thrown after a batter has completed her at-bat.

Step out from behind the catcher, do not let the pitcher throw another pitch. If necessary, you might add "that's four" to the oblivious batter who has walked; or "that's three" to the oblivious batter who has struck out. If everyone is just staring at you, you might want to ask your partner "what count do YOU have?"

[mcrowder]

I would only add "that's four" after the defense has gotten the ball to pitcher, and I still have a clueless batter/coaching staff. I hate when umpires say "Ball", and then realizing batter is still there add either "Take your base" or "That's four" before the defense has gotten the ball back (even worse when they do this when there's a stolen base going on). If the Batter-runner chooses not to run, don't remind them until there's NO chance that your reminder will give them an advantage (like the possibility of an extra base if the ball gets away somewhere).