A walk is as good as a hit...maybe

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by jimpiano

Of course I would, but you have totally changed the scenario.

We were discussing game ending scenarios on a bases loaded walk.

OK, please cite the rule that makes the duties of the runners and the availability of defensive appeals different in a "game ending" bases loaded walk and any other bases loaded walk. Again, rule, please? The generic "run scores" rule doesn't work since that generic "run scores" rule is always subject to a valid appeal. So, your case boils down to these are not valid appeals because it involves the winning run in the bottom of the 7th.

Again, I say, rule, please?