Missed base appeals

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Okay, now I'll just sit back and wait for someone to say something stupid.

While I am perfectly capable of saying something stupid (as I have demonstrated here and elsewhere from time to time), I would like to point out that my listing of possible rulings above does not mean that is how I would rule; only that it is how I have read others say they would rule.

Besides, I never did baseball umpiring and don't have a clear understanding of what the "last time by" theory actually is.