Force play

[bbman]

Are 'accidendal' force plays allowed?

[Insane Blue]

what is an accidental force out?

[bbman]

Accidental appeal

[Cecil4]

An appeal must obviously be intended as an appeal.
A fielder touching a base while running off the field is not an appeal, even if a runner missed it.

[Altor]

Agree with Cecil on the "accidental appeal".

Can we revisit the original question about an "accidental force"? Scenario:
Bases loaded, two outs, two strikes. Batter swings and misses on ball in the dirt and takes off toward first. Catcher digs the ball out of the dirt and decides to throw to 2B to get the out. As she steps to make the throw, she steps on the plate.

[Tru_in_Blu]

Originally Posted by Altor

Agree with Cecil on the "accidental appeal".

Can we revisit the original question about an "accidental force"? Scenario:
Bases loaded, two outs, two strikes. Batter swings and misses on ball in the dirt and takes off toward first. Catcher digs the ball out of the dirt and decides to throw to 2B to get the out. As she steps to make the throw, she steps on the plate.

If F2 has control of the ball when she steps on the plate, I have an out.

8.7.C

When, on a force play, a fielder contacts the base while holding the ball or tags the
runner before the runner reaches the base.

Sorry for the spacing. Copy/paste being a little weird.