Getting it right

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by AtlUmpSteve

5) BUT, if BU truly believes he/she didn't have a good look, then, do the right thing(s); yes, ask PU what PU saw, and if PU is absolutely sure the call needs to be changes, then BU should change the call.

Yes, neither umpire did the mechanics correctly, maybe I should have stated that conspicuously in the OP.

With that, the above is the only answer to my OP question:
"Is this appropriate and acceptable?"

I do appreciate all the detail and other examples.