We're Not Measuring!

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Texas Aggie

Was it grass or turf? If grass, I'd probably go ahead and measure. Field could be off; of course, so could the chains. I had a game once where the 39 and 40 yard line on one side of the field where almost touching each other! We told the V coach and said on anything close we'd measure. If you're on turf, then I'd be inclined to tell them the turf is more accurate than the chains.

Its your decision as to what's reasonable, but if its close, a possible change of possession, and/or a critical point in a varsity game, I'm going to measure. Last night we measured twice when I was 100% sure he was a yard short. Just feel like its easier to show them rather than try to explain why we didn't. Obviously, anything unreasonable we're not going to do it.

The field *could* be off.

That doesn't matter to me -- if we spot it on exactly the 35 for 1st and 10, it has to reach the 45 *on that field* for a first down. Matter of fact, I'll argue that this is a reason to *never* measure in this situation -- otherwise, how can we ever use the field markings? If the ball reaches the 45, we're not measuring if it's an inch beyond -- it's a first down and I'm moving the chains. Are some of you saying you'd measure *that* one too?

Hell, we use the field to measure the chains -- how do I *know* for a fact that the chains are *exactly* 10 yards apart?

By the way, I've never had a coach continue to argue when we've said, "We started on exactly the 35 -- you need the 45 for a first down." Coaches get that, in my experience.

I will bring the chains out (technically, the line judge (not me) makes that decision) when I know we haven't reached the LTG, though -- if the ball's in the side zone and the spot is crucial, I'll use the chains to move the football. We've been through 4 full weeks of varsity, JV, and freshman, and we've had the chains out exactly twice. I'm not allergic to bringing them out, but I'm only bringing them out when I feel it's needed.

(Funny how some chain crews we work with notice how many series start on a 5-yard line and how virtually all of them start on a 1-yard line. That's not accidental, of course.)

[Robert Goodman]

Originally Posted by Rich

The field *could* be off.

That doesn't matter to me -- if we spot it on exactly the 35 for 1st and 10, it has to reach the 45 *on that field* for a first down. Matter of fact, I'll argue that this is a reason to *never* measure in this situation -- otherwise, how can we ever use the field markings?

I agree. What if the goal line is crooked? Would you award a score on the basis of the ball's being dead where the end zone should have been marked?

I would make an exception for crooked goal posts, though. If an upright is bent and the ball is kicked beyond its vertical extent, I'm not projecting that angled line into space to judge whether a FG try succeeded. But that's only because it's a projection; if the ball passed inside or outside the physical post itself, that still counts.

[ajmc]

Life is a lot easier and games go a lot smoother when you believe, and accept, all lines are perfectly straight, and are exactly 5 and/or 10 yards apart.

[CT1]

Originally Posted by ajmc

Life is a lot easier and games go a lot smoother when you believe, and accept, all lines are perfectly straight, and are exactly 5 and/or 10 yards apart.

Fair for one, fair for all.

[Matt-MI]

I worked on a field that was lined after a"Three Martini Lunch". A ball at one hash mark could be a first down and a yard short on the opposite hash. The only lines remotely straight were the sidelines which the guy did before lunch. When he numbered the yard lines he forgot the 10 yd line at one end and we had two 50 yd lines.

[Tom.OH]

Originally Posted by Matt-MI

I worked on a field that was lined after a"Three Martini Lunch". A ball at one hash mark could be a first down and a yard short on the opposite hash. The only lines remotely straight were the sidelines which the guy did before lunch. When he numbered the yard lines he forgot the 10 yd line at one end and we had two 50 yd lines.

Matt, I have also worked on the "same" field!