This happened at least 5 times in OHSAA Finals!

[kdf5]

Are you sure it was at least five times? Could it have been less than five? Are you sure you got them all counted? It's imperative that we know the exact number in order to give you our best guess as to what the guys on the field saw and why they ruled like they did.

[Ia-Ref]

Was the QB out of the tackle box?

I was at a game where the back judge threw the flag for intentional gounding. Really. He missed the spot of the foul by about 20 yards.
There was no doubt about the intent as the ball hit about lane 8 of the track surrounding the field.
When I was talking to the opposite wing official later, he said the coach (whose QB threw the ball) didn't have a problem with the call. It was that obvious. Except to maybe the R.

[bigjohn]

Anyone that watched all six final games like I did knows what I am talking about.

[bigjohn]

the referee will have to judge whether
the pass was intentionally thrown incomplete or whether A1 was simply unable
to throw the ball close to A3.


Pretty easy to tell when a kid is dumping the ball 25 yards out of bounds to prevent a sack. I wish they would just take IG out of the NFHS rules altogether.

[asdf]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

Pretty easy to tell when a kid is dumping the ball 25 yards out of bounds to prevent a sack. I wish they would just take IG out of the NFHS rules altogether.

Knowing that both stadiums have very little room between the sideline and the stands, dumping the ball 25 yards out of bounds would put the ball at least 10 rows deep into the seats.

Didn't happen..... Go away.....

[bigjohn]

Oh, it happened!

[asdf]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

Oh, it happened!

25 yards out of bounds

You are not a very good liar.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

Oh, it happened!

Hmmm... 25 yards out of bounds, plus 25 more between the middle of the field and the sideline... plus some sort of angle to make this a forward pass... let's give the benefit of the doubt and say he's moved halfway to the sideline, and the pass is at a 45 degree angle. That's 53+ yards in the air. This kid throw that far?

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

the referee will have to judge whether
the pass was intentionally thrown incomplete or whether A1 was simply unable
to throw the ball close to A3.


Pretty easy to tell when a kid is dumping the ball 25 yards out of bounds to prevent a sack. I wish they would just take IG out of the NFHS rules altogether.

Did it ever occur to you that maybe officials view this rule differently than you do? You say it is obvious and it is not called, but for some reason officials do not agree with you on this when they are on the field. That is telling if you ask me.

Peace

[APG]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

the referee will have to judge whether
the pass was intentionally thrown incomplete or whether A1 was simply unable
to throw the ball close to A3. I wish they would just take IG out of the NFHS rules altogether.

Not that I'm in a state that uses NFHS for football, but really? I'm sure coaches all over your state are clamoring to allow QBs to ground the ball as they please!

[asdf]

He got a million e-mails from coaches that agree with him.