Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:
Originally posted by Mike Simonds
In your example A's choices would be to decline the penalty (B's ball 1st and 10) or enforce the illegal participation penalty 15 yards from the previous spot (A's ball at the 15 yard line) or enforce the face mask penalty from the end of the run (A's ball at the 12 1/2).
|
I have to disagree, Mike. This is penalized under the All But One. Mark off from the basic spot.
9-4-1 is marked off from the previous spot. 9-4-2,3,4 are penalized under All But One.
|
I must disagree with your disagreement
Isn't illegal participation where twelve players are in the formation at the snap a foul simultaneous with the snap according to the case book? If it is a foul simultaneous with the snap, then it is enforced from the previous spot if accepted.
It makes sense to penalize this when twelve players are in the formation because how do we determine who wasn't supposed to be on the field and who illegally participated?
Sun Aug 25, 2002, 08:11pm
Threaded Mode
