Complete Pass, Tack on RTP?

[FredFan7]

NFHS:

THird and 10 for team A at its own 20. Team A completes a pass to the 50 yard line. Team B is guilty of roughing the passer. Do you tack on the yardage?

This is a loose ball play so usually the answer is no tack on; the spot of enforcement is the previous spot (A20) so A would have to decline the penalty to keep the play to the 50. I'll go look it up in the book, but I thought I'd also ask here.

[Reffing Rev.]

Roughing the Passer is one of the exceptions... Roughing the passer is always enforced from the the end of the last run when the last run ends beyond the neutral zone. So in other words...yes...1st and 10 at the B 35.

This enforcement is also one of those reasons its really nice to remember to bag fumbles beyond the LOS.

A1's pass is complete to A80 who fumbles the ball at the 50. B recovers the ball at the 45 and is downed immediately. B99 is called for roughing the passer on the play. Enforcement is from the end of the last run which ended at the 50. So 1st and 10 at the 35.

[ppaltice]

Originally Posted by Reffing Rev.

Roughing the Passer is one of the exceptions... Roughing the passer is always enforced from the the end of the last run when the last run ends beyond the neutral zone. So in other words...yes...1st and 10 at the B 35.

This enforcement is also one of those reasons its really nice to remember to bag fumbles beyond the LOS.

A1's pass is complete to A80 who fumbles the ball at the 50. B recovers the ball at the 45 and is downed immediately. B99 is called for roughing the passer on the play. Enforcement is from the end of the last run which ended at the 50. So 1st and 10 at the 35.

The rule is for roughing the passer the enforcement spot is the end of the last run when the run ends beyond the neutral zone and there has been no change of possession.

The case you presented has a changed of possession. So enforcement from previous spot.

[mbyron]

ppaltice is correct.

Originally Posted by Rule 9-5-4

PENALTY:
... Roughing passer (Art. 4) – (S34) – 15 yards and a first down
from end of last run when last run ends beyond the neutral zone and there has
been no change of team possession, or otherwise 15 yards and first down from
previous spot.

[Reffing Rev.]

Interesting...

i was told by the MO state interpreter at a clinic a couple of years ago that the COP part of RTP refers to when the COP occurs before there is a run beyond the NZ by team A. In other words if Team A does not have a run beyond the NZ then it would be previous spot enforcement. I know this because the play I posted is exactly what happened on the field, and what you say is exactly how we enforced it, but the clinician and interpreter told us we were wrong.

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by Reffing Rev.

Interesting...

i was told by the MO state interpreter at a clinic a couple of years ago that the COP part of RTP refers to when the COP occurs before there is a run beyond the NZ by team A. In other words if Team A does not have a run beyond the NZ then it would be previous spot enforcement. I know this because the play I posted is exactly what happened on the field, and what you say is exactly how we enforced it, but the clinician and interpreter told us we were wrong.

End-of-run enforcement applies, as the rule plainly says, when the "last run ends beyond the neutral zone AND there has been no change of team possession." By that rule, we should use previous spot enforcement if EITHER (a) the last run ended in or behind the NZ OR (b) there is a change of possession. Since your play involves a COP, it should be previous spot enforcement.

Perhaps your experts were thinking of this case play:

Originally Posted by Case Book

9.4.4 SITUATION C: A1’s pass on fourth and 15 from A’s 40 is complete to A2
at midfield. During the pass, A1 is roughed by B1. A2 advances to B’s 30 where
he fumbles the ball out of bounds at B’s: (a) 28-, or (b) 32-yard line. RULING: In
both (a) and (b), if the penalty is accepted, it is administered from the end of A2’s
run which is B’s 30-yard line.

The difference here is that this play involves no COP: hence end-of-run enforcement. The rule does not mention that enforcement depends on where a COP occurs -- your experts seem to have made that up. Given the details of your play, I still conclude that you got the enforcement correct, your experts' opinions notwithstanding.

The rule also seems fair to me: if the offense completes the pass despite RTP and doesn't turn the ball over, end-of-run enforcement provides additional disincentive for RTP; if, however, they complete the pass only to turn it over, take that failure into account and enforce from the previous spot.

[JugglingReferee]

Originally Posted by FredFan7

NFHS:

Third and 10 for team A at its own 20. Team A completes a pass to the 50 yard line. Team B is guilty of roughing the passer. Do you tack on the yardage?

This is a loose ball play so usually the answer is no tack on; the spot of enforcement is the previous spot (A20) so A would have to decline the penalty to keep the play to the 50. I'll go look it up in the book, but I thought I'd also ask here.

CANADIAN RULING:

RTP is a UR foul, which is applied at either PLS or PBD.

Result: Team A 1D/10 @ B-40.

[Robert Goodman]

Originally Posted by JugglingReferee

CANADIAN RULING:

RTP is a UR foul, which is applied at either PLS or PBD.

And that's true because Canadian football has no end-of-run enforcements per se, right? So it's consistent with running plays.

[JugglingReferee]

Originally Posted by Robert Goodman

And that's true because Canadian football has no end-of-run enforcements per se, right? So it's consistent with running plays.

Correct. But you knew that.