Illegal Sub? - or nothing?

[waltjp]

Originally Posted by Theisey

I also happen to agree with Redding interpretation this on.

However, there is a conflict between the two sources of information that really needs to be corrected.

I agree that this is no foul and have gotten into 2 pretty heated conversations this week while trying to defend my position. And I'm just considering a simple mistake, player runs off and then back on. If there was an attempt to deceive then yes, penalize.

The odd thing is that both sources have this marked as a change for this year. I checked last year's Redding guide, which says it's illegal BUT that was marked as a change from 2004.