Fair Catch

[mcrowder]

Originally Posted by Middleman

Well, here's some food for thought ... the actual rule says "The captain may choose to free kick or snap ... on the yard line through the spot of the catch ..." If a psk foul is enforced following a fair catch, the ball will not be placed on the yard line through the spot of the catch.

So what ARE you going to allow after a psk foul? Apparently something other than a free kick or snap!

Seriously - I see your point, but if you use this rule as strictly as it seems you want to, the captain has NO choices. You can't invalidate the free kick option using your logic without also invalidating the snap option.