Baylor @ OK State Block/Charge (Video)

[APG]

[APG]

One could also discuss whether under NCAA-M interpretation, whether this should have been in the act of shooting. Should the center have provided information to the calling official (assuming he had any)? Would you give that information to the calling official if you were in the C's position (assuming you had it before the act)?

[just another ref]

The pivot foot returns to the floor before the ball is released.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by just another ref

The pivot foot returns to the floor before the ball is released.

Right foot pivot. Never comes back down.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by Rich

Right foot pivot. Never comes back down.

Holding the ball in two hands with the left foot on the floor outside the 3 point line.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Holding the ball in two hands with the left foot on the floor outside the 3 point line.

Agree....he has the ball in both hands with it above his head with his left foot still on the ground. Left foot is the pivot. Travel.

But he was fouled first....and it was a block.

[zm1283]

I thought it was a travel when first watching it, but the contact does happen before his left foot (Which was his pivot foot) comes back down to the floor.

Those that have a block...why? Not disagreeing yet, just interested in your reasoning.

Anyone think the Lead was too wide?

[Rich]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Holding the ball in two hands with the left foot on the floor outside the 3 point line.

Barely...I won't disagree. Real time, realistically, I'd probably consider the gather to be in the air, which makes the right foot the pivot.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by APG

One could also discuss whether under NCAA-M interpretation, whether this should have been in the act of shooting. Should the center have provided information to the calling official (assuming he had any)? Would you give that information to the calling official if you were in the C's position (assuming you had it before the act)?

only if he asked

[APG]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

only if the asked

Would time and score change your opinion? I'm also guessing who your assignor is would change that as well?

[Adam]

I wouldn't have been able to get that travel in real time.

I've got a PC foul.

If he calls a block, with the NCAA change to "upward motion" being the start of the shooting motion, this would be a foul before the shot.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Adam

I wouldn't have been able to get that travel in real time.

I've got a PC foul.

If he calls a block, with the NCAA change to "upward motion" being the start of the shooting motion, this would be a foul before the shot.

I think the "travel" posts are in reference to the fact that by the time he released the shot he had traveled, so we shouldn't be counting the basket.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I think the "travel" posts are in reference to the fact that by the time he released the shot he had traveled, so we shouldn't be counting the basket.

That's what I was saying. From the angle we have, it's difficult to make the block/charge call. With what we have, I thought it was a charge. But, as Cameron says, if the contact is mainly on the leg, it's a block.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by just another ref

That's what I was saying. From the angle we have, it's difficult to make the block/charge call. With what we have, I thought it was a charge. But, as Cameron says, if the contact is mainly on the leg, it's a block.

That is not what the rule says. Nowhere does it say contact against a defender's leg is a block.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by Adam

That is not what the rule says. Nowhere does it say contact against a defender's leg is a block.

10-6-1: A player shall not.......impede the progress of an opponent by extending arm(s), shoulder(s), hip(s), or knee(s)........