Foul or incidental contact?
I have an example from my game a couple weeks ago. My guy goes to set a screen for the ballhandler, the ball handler gives a fake, but drives away from the screen. The defender goes for the fake, makes contact with my guy setting a screen. He gets called for an illegal screen. I agree that my guy was not completely set when contact was made, so if he used the screen, I would have agreed with the call. The way it went down, I thought it was incidental contact. Your thoughts?
|
Still slowed him down
The contact probably slowed his reaction and recovery going back the other way, so I've got no problem with the foul call.
|
This is really a HTBT situation. I can see why a foul was called, but hard to say for sure without seeing the play.
Peace |
Quote:
Coach, you gotta start taping your games! Just say it's for a highlight video or something but secretly funnel that video to us ;) |
Since there's actually no foul that's called an illegal screen, your player was called for a blocking foul. It makes no difference whether the dribbler "used the screen" or not. If your player as moving and blocked the defender's path, that's a foul.
|
Quote:
Also, doesn't the defender's path have to be a path that affects the play? Otherwise, couldn't I simply tell my guys to run into moving offensive players and I'll get a foul call? |
Quote:
|
We need a description of the contact to say whether or not it was a foul.
|
Tough to decide from a written description.
Screens do not have to be anywhere near the player with the ball. This could be an example of an illegal off-ball screen or it could be a defender illegally contacting a cutting offensive player. These are the difficult judgment decisions officials must make hundreds of times during games. I wish that I could offer the coach more feedback, but some plays just come down to what a particular person sees and thinks at a certain point in the game. |
Screens ...
Quote:
The blocking foul is called due to illegal contact (block) as described as illegal activity in the principles of screening. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The rule is "contact which prevents a player from performing normal offensive or defensive movements" (paraphrased from memory). Assuming the contact did that, and the screener wasn't legal when contact was made. |
Quote:
|
Is This German to the Point?
Quote:
I'd prefer it termed it "blocking", which explains why that's the signal I most frequently use cuz it makes sense. Though this citation might not actually address the original post... |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:29am. |