is this a foul? (Video)

[Indianaref]

I will defer to the calling official, he has the best look as opposed to a grainy video image from the stands.

[bob jenkins]

It appears that Jeremy just discovered youtube.

[jeremy341a]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

It appears that Jeremy just discovered youtube.

Lol Actually I found a site that had a link to all these plays and as the video discussions are my favorite part of this site I thought I would help start some vs. just reading everyone else's. It has been kind of slow here lately with the season winding down.

[jeremy341a]

I agree there may have been contact with the arm. However the time of whistle indicates that he was calling a foul for the contract right before that. If there is no arm contact do you feel the contact of the bodies warrants a foul?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by jeremy341a

I agree there may have been contact with the arm. However the time of whistle indicates that he was calling a foul for the contract right before that. If there is no arm contact do you feel the contact of the bodies warrants a foul?

there *could* be a foul on the trailing defender or on the secondary defender.

[jeremy341a]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

there *could* be a foul on the trailing defender or on the secondary defender.

When he reports the foul he uses two hands so I believe he calls it on the secondary defender. Do you feel her body contact should warrant a foul? I am not second guessing the official as he sees a foul somewhere but I am curious about the body contact for my own self.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by jeremy341a

When he reports the foul he uses two hands so I believe he calls it on the secondary defender. Do you feel her body contact should warrant a foul? I am not second guessing the official as he sees a foul somewhere but I am curious about the body contact for my own self.

Impossible to tell from the video -- except that it was an exceptionally "ugly" shot which *tends* to point to some disadvantage.