Deflected Throw-In Goes In
Older threads went back and forth on this, and I'd like to renew the question so as to settle on a firm, rules-based judgment on this situation:
Throw-in thrown toward throw-in team's basket deflects off a defender standing outside the three-point arc and goes through the basket. Result is two points due to the fact that the "throw" did not originate "from the field" as requisite in 5-2-1. True or False? Previous threads from a while ago wavered back and forth until seemingly settling on the "two points" result. Casebook does not seem to settle the question since all sitches there deal with passes and throws from a player inbounds. Any rules-based insights you can share with me? |
Quote:
|
NCAA-W AR 104 and 106.A lead me toward saying it...I still don't know. Someone smarter than me provide some amazing insight here.
Quote:
|
No way can this be three points.
|
Quote:
|
My opinion is ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
I would rule the same way in FED. And to the OP -- if it wasn't resolved then, and there haven't been any (relevant) changes, what makes you think it would be resolved now? |
The throw-in ended when the ball was legally touched by the defender. There was never a throw (shot attempt) made by an offensive player. So the rules cited do not really apply. This would be two points.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
With that same scenario, what if time expires while the ball is in flight..do you count the basket or wave off the basket?
|
Score two points in the OP.
Quote:
|
Quote:
(Same as if the ball was thrown toward the opponent's basket.) |
I agree with the 2-points rulings here, but I'd want to be careful not to mistakenly state that it's 2 because "you can score a 3-pt. basket from a throw-in," since the throw-in technically ended on the defensive deflection - even though that's essentially how we're logically getting there.
|
Sorry. Wait, No I'm Not
Quote:
In the previous threads from a while ago many posters confused this situation with those in the casebook which do not deal with a throw in. And I see at least one responder to this thread made the same error. I asked the question again for the sake of clarity and confirmation and I thank you for your responses. :) But because I may have discomforted some with my request I will be sure to seek permission before asking anything like this again. :D |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:30pm. |