Possible CE, MN/MSU

[billyu2]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

And what actions would you have done to 'correct' the original error at this point?

This is one of most stupidly written and applied rules in the book.

I have this situation where the wrong shooter shot and we wiped out the rebounding foul. Don't feel bad about doing it.

Instead of the foul on the rebound, let's say the rebounding team advanced the ball down the court and scored at which time the error was recognized. Would you have cancelled the basket?

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by billyu2

Instead of the foul on the rebound, let's say the rebounding team advanced the ball down the court and scored at which time the error was recognized. Would you have cancelled the basket?

Willing to cancel foul if next foul occurs during rebounding action. And wish rule was written to legally do so. Otherwise in the case of an unmerited free throw what are we really correcting in the OP.

I'm not some 1st year JV official who is ignorant of the rule. Unlike some folks here I acknowdge when I'm doing something outside the letter of the rules and I'm willing to eat the consequences if there are any.

[HawkeyeCubP]

Originally Posted by billyu2

Instead of the foul on the rebound, let's say the rebounding team advanced the ball down the court and scored at which time the error was recognized. Would you have cancelled the basket?

Nope. All action after the FT would stand, including time consumed, points scored, and fouls committed. Then the ball would be put back into play at the POI, which would be a throw-in to the team that didn't make that last basket from anywhere along that end line.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by HawkeyeCubP

Nope. All action after the FT would stand, including time consumed, points scored, and fouls committed. Then the ball would be put back into play at the POI, which would be a throw-in to the team that didn't make that last basket from anywhere along that end line.

So essentially all you're doing is what if the CE was an unmerited free throw that was missed?

[HawkeyeCubP]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

So essentially all you're doing is what if the CE was an unmerited free throw that was missed?

Yep. But if it were my game, it'd help save some of what little a$$ I have left with my supervisor, at least (and that FT shooter's percentage for stat purposes).

[Adam]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

So essentially all you're doing is what if the CE was an unmerited free throw that was missed?

In this case, even though it was a CE, correcting it would have simply involved removing the attempt from the stat book. Irrelevant to us, but there's nothing else to do.

[HawkeyeCubP]

Originally Posted by Adam

In this case, even though it was a CE, correcting it would have simply involved removing the attempt from the stat book. Irrelevant to us, but there's nothing else to do.

Isn't that what I said?

[Adam]

Originally Posted by HawkeyeCubP

Isn't that what I said?

Yeah, sorry. hadn't read all the posts yet.