![]() |
NF 4-44-5 Traveling
During a scramble for a loose ball, A1 gets possession of the ball, while on both knees. With no defensive pressure, A1 moves one leg from from having the knee on the floor to a foot. There is no apparent "...attempt to get up or stand." -- NF 4-44-5 b. A1 then passes the ball to a A2 and play continues.
Coach B protests that the knee to foot movement is traveling. Is there any written statement that changing the position of one leg from knee contact with the floor to foot contact, constitutes an "attempt to get up or stand" and thus a traveling violation? |
Judgment call
|
Traveling. Going from a knee to a foot IS part of an attempt to get up. You could break the "get up" in to many small pieces and they'd still be part of getting up.
The only movement allowed in an "updward" manner is sitting up if they are on their back. |
Quote:
|
Gotta agree with Mr. Rust. Why else would the player go from the knee to the foot unless they are making an effort to stand up? Sounds like a travel to me.
|
I'm not sure I disagree, I'm just not sure I agree either. I think it might be similar to using a pivot foot. Not trying to get up, but getting the balance needed to make the pass. I don't know - I just think the wording in the rules makes it too vague to say with absolute certainty.
|
Quote:
I generally allow them to get up before blowing instead of making interpretations about what the player was trying to accomplish. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
Any call we can make via a discernable act, rather than via judgment, makes thing more objective than subjective, and is better for everyone involved. |
Quote:
|
Favorite Color Is Gray ???
Quote:
|
Quote:
Thats the reason why I would wait & see if a knee to foot is an truly an attempt to get up or just an attempt to get off that sore knee. I believe there is a difference. Afterall, whenever I attempt to get up, I always wind up in a standing position on my feet. IMO, being patient on violations & giving ourselves a chance to replay it in our minds before blowing is the best practice. In the OP he passed the ball immediately after going knee to foot. Too bad we cant see the play. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:47pm. |