The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Book It, It's The Fashion Police ... (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/89214-book-its-fashion-police.html)

BillyMac Sun Feb 19, 2012 02:23pm

Book It, It's The Fashion Police ...
 
Prep school game yesterday. Black is warming up before the game. Three Black players are wearing black "leggings". Tights? Long socks? Who knows? My partner and I chose to ignore, which surely makes us part of the problem, not part of the solution. We're just kicking the can down the road to the next "Fashion Police" officials, as previous officials had obviously done to us.

Black is warming up with all players wearing warmup jackets. As the game progresses, and more players take off their warmup jackets, and come off the bench into the game, I note that a few Black players had black arm compression sleeves, and one Black player had a white arm compression sleeve. It was late in the first half by the time I noted this, so I waited until halftime to approach a Black assistant coach and tell him that all the players must have the same color arm compression sleeves to participate in the second half. He says that he'll take care of it, and he did. The black sleeves came off, and the player with the white sleeve kept his on.

As I'm waiting at the division line to administer the throwin to Black to start the second half, the Black throwin player politely asks me about the arm compression sleeves. I reply that they all must be the same color. A nearby Black player asks me about his black "tights". I reply that I wasn't sure if they were tights, or very long socks. Throwin player says to me, "Hey. This is getting weird". He was right, it was weird, and it would have felt weirder with female players.

When it comes to issues of proper uniforms, and equipment, I'm usually a "Fashion Police Son Of A Bit*h". Illegal undershirts? Illegal headbands? Illegal wrist bands? Illegal arm compression sleeves? Go to jail. Do not pass go. Do not collect two hundred dollars.

That's when it comes to proper uniforms, and equipment, above the waist. In the past, I have generally ignored anything below the waist. But lately, tights have become more, and more, popular, among both players, and officials.

How do you handle this issue? When you note these while watching the warmups, exactly what do you say? "You can't wear tights". "Are those tights?" What are those you're wearing?" Do any of you ignore them, as we did yesterday, secretly hoping they are really just very long socks? Are you more "timid" asking girls about this issue? Are we "can kickers", or are we "Fashion Police Sons Of Bit*hes"?

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5251/5...ca118730_m.jpg

ga314ref Sun Feb 19, 2012 08:50pm

If they're tights...
 
...and we know they're tights, they can't participate while wearing them. We notify the head coach, and they're expected to deal with it.

Welpe Sun Feb 19, 2012 08:53pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ga314ref (Post 825853)
...and we know they're tights, they can't participate while wearing them. We notify the head coach, and they're expected to deal with it.

What he said. Leg sleeves are probably the next thing NFHS needs to address.

billyu2 Sun Feb 19, 2012 09:25pm

It's really not that hard.
 
Girls game last week. One girl on the visiting team during warmups was wearing what appeared to be either long socks or tights. Didn't ignore it, just asked her, "are those socks or tights?" She replied they were tights. I told her she can't play wearing tights. She left the floor and removed them.
Girls tournament game yesterday: two girls wearing ribbons. Partner told them the ribbons had to be removed. They complied but of course they came up with "We've worn ribbons the last two years." I told my partner I knew that wasn't true because I had this team twice this season and no one wore ribbons.

26 Year Gap Sun Feb 19, 2012 09:29pm

Saw the highlights on the Tampa station of a local regional game a couple nights ago. Headband with logo. So, even if you try to enforce it, someone else will not.

Nevadaref Mon Feb 20, 2012 12:06am

Quote:

Originally Posted by 26 Year Gap (Post 825860)
Saw the highlights on the Tampa station of a local regional game a couple nights ago. Headband with logo. So, even if you try to enforce it, someone else will not.

Or perhaps that someone else actually knows the correct rule! :p

A headband MAY have a logo as long as it meets the size requirements.

Rule 3
SECTION 6 LOGO/TRADEMARK/REFERENCE
ART. 1 . . .
One visible manufacturer’s logo/trademark/reference or school
logo/mascot is permitted on the wristbands, headband, compression shorts and arm compression sleeve. (3-5-3, 3-5-4, 3-5-7).

ART. 2 . . .
The size shall be limited to 2¼ square inches and shall not exceed 2¼ inches in any dimension on any item.


Nevadaref Mon Feb 20, 2012 12:07am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 825699)
Prep school game yesterday. Black is warming up before the game. Three Black players are wearing black "leggings". Tights? Long socks? Who knows? My partner and I chose to ignore, which surely makes us part of the problem, not part of the solution. We're just kicking the can down the road to the next "Fashion Police" officials, as previous officials had obviously done to us.

Black is warming up with all players wearing warmup jackets. As the game progresses, and more players take off their warmup jackets, and come off the bench into the game, I note that a few Black players had black arm compression sleeves, and one Black player had a white arm compression sleeve. It was late in the first half by the time I noted this, so I waited until halftime to approach a Black assistant coach and tell him that all the players must have the same color arm compression sleeves to participate in the second half. He says that he'll take care of it, and he did. The black sleeves came off, and the player with the white sleeve kept his on.

As I'm waiting at the division line to administer the throwin to Black to start the second half, the Black throwin player politely asks me about the arm compression sleeves. I reply that they all must be the same color. A nearby Black player asks me about his black "tights". I reply that I wasn't sure if they were tights, or very long socks. Throwin player says to me, "Hey. This is getting weird". He was right, it was weird, and it would have felt weirder with female players.

When it comes to issues of proper uniforms, and equipment, I'm usually a "Fashion Police Son Of A Bit*h". Illegal undershirts? Illegal headbands? Illegal wrist bands? Illegal arm compression sleeves? Go to jail. Do not pass go. Do not collect two hundred dollars.

That's when it comes to proper uniforms, and equipment, above the waist. In the past, I have generally ignored anything below the waist. But lately, tights have become more, and more, popular, among both players, and officials.

How do you handle this issue? When you note these while watching the warmups, exactly what do you say? "You can't wear tights". "Are those tights?" What are those you're wearing?" Do any of you ignore them, as we did yesterday, secretly hoping they are really just very long socks? Are you more "timid" asking girls about this issue? Are we "can kickers", or are we "Fashion Police Sons Of Bit*hes"?

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5251/5...ca118730_m.jpg

Billy,
Don't make me tell you that you are acting cowardly. Now get out there and enforce the rules as you should!

BillyMac Mon Feb 20, 2012 07:19am

Sounds Legal To Me ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by billyu2 (Post 825857)
two girls wearing ribbons. Partner told them the ribbons had to be removed. They complied but of course they came up with "We've worn ribbons the last two years."

Headbands go around the head. Hair control devices go around hair. There are no color restrictions on hair control devices as there are on headbands. However, they must be used to control hair, not as hair decorations.

NFHS 3-5-4-D: Rubber, cloth or elastic bands may be used to control hair. Hard items, including, but not limited to, beads, barrettes and bobby pins, are prohibited.

BillyMac Mon Feb 20, 2012 07:23am

From Now On, No More Tights ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 825896)
Don't make me tell you that you are acting cowardly. Now get out there and enforce the rules as you should!

I hope that I wasn't being cowardly, I was just trying to not be an overly officious official. I also got "enforce the rules as you should" advice from a top notch veteran official who I greatly respect when I discussed this situation with him.

http://ts2.mm.bing.net/images/thumbn...98fe48c7dc76b4

JetMetFan Mon Feb 20, 2012 07:39am

Aww, come on...
 
I actually like the Cowardly Lion :)

At any rate, I've wondered why some of my brethren don't like dealing with uniform issues. The fact that NFHS - and NCAA - keep emphasizing them every year means the rules makers (i.e., coaches) want these things dealt with.

I had a game last Feb. involving teams I hadn't seen before. The home team wore warmups during the pre-game and as they came on the court for the jump ball I noticed their starting point guard was wearing a maroon undershirt under his white jersey. I told coach he needed to take it off and was met with, "This is ridiculous! We're 18 games into the season and no one has told my kid to take this off before!" My response: "Coach, I can't speak to what anyone else has done but the rule is he can't play with that on." He took it off.

Unfortunately, being the fashion police is part of our job now. Taking care of business may be a pain but I'd rather be a pain for doing what I'm supposed to do. That coach could've complained to my assignor forever but I had the rule book on my side.

Welpe Mon Feb 20, 2012 08:16am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 825938)
Headbands go around the head. Hair control devices go around hair. There are no color restrictions on hair control devices as there are on headbands.

NFHS 3-5-4-D: Rubber, cloth or elastic bands may be used to control hair. Hard items, including, but not limited to, beads, barrettes and bobby pins, are prohibited.

Keep looking Billy...

3-5-4-e

Head decorations and headwear, except those specified above, are prohibited.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JetMetFan
At any rate, I've wondered why some of my brethren don't like dealing with uniform issues.

Agreed. Take care of it early and move on. They may gripe but as you said, the rules are on our side. We really have no excuse in my chapter because the chapter leadership has stated time and again that they want this taken care of.

olsont1977 Mon Feb 20, 2012 08:35am

Girls are the worst.... in many ways
 
The thing that drives me crazy as a high school girls coach is having one team follow all the uniform/dress codes and then have another team express themselves with ....... socks. Not white or black shin high socks, but tie-dye knee length explosions of color. And then they trade with each other. We had a game where the top six from another team all had one tie-dye sock up to their knee and then a black or white one up to the shin. At least they all wore the tie-dye one on their left leg. Girls.

Welpe Mon Feb 20, 2012 08:37am

Quote:

Originally Posted by olsont1977 (Post 825952)
The thing that drives me crazy as a high school girls coach is having one team follow all the uniform/dress codes and then have another team express themselves with ....... socks. Not white or black shin high socks, but tie-dye knee length explosions of color. And then they trade with each other. We had a game where the top six from another team all had one tie-dye sock up to their knee and then a black or white one up to the shin. At least they all wore the tie-dye one on their left leg. Girls.

Whatever you do, please don't raise this as an issue with the Federation...the last thing I want to do is become the sock police also. :eek:

Rufus Mon Feb 20, 2012 09:54am

I'm making the transition from sub-varsity to varsity and so am usually the U2 with two more experienced officials. In those situations I will ask if we're being uniform police tonight and follow their lead (i.e., when in Rome). I don't feel great about doing that but at least the subject is brought up.

If I'm the R for any game, however, the uniform rules get enforced as written.

It's interesting that in an avocation that is prone to so much judgment and interpretation for just about everything there can be such an issue with something that is so clearly defined.

26 Year Gap Mon Feb 20, 2012 10:13am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rufus (Post 825974)
I'm making the transition from sub-varsity to varsity and so am usually the U2 with two more experienced officials. In those situations I will ask if we're being uniform police tonight and follow their lead (i.e., when in Rome). I don't feel great about doing that but at least the subject is brought up.

If I'm the R for any game, however, the uniform rules get enforced as written.

It's interesting that in an avocation that is prone to so much judgment and interpretation for just about everything there can be such an issue with something that is so clearly defined.

I know I feel better if they are enforced by the R. Because I know that if those details are tended to, that if an unusual situation arises, proper enforcement and/or administration of the rules is likely.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:59pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1