![]() |
Simultaneous whistles
Two whistle game with A1 driving in the lane toward his basket when he enters heavy traffic. Partner @ lead whistles a hit on his side of A1 and I whistle one on my side. We get together and determine his foul occurred first and penalize only that foul. Is there ever a situation where one would penalize both?
|
Quote:
4-19-11 A multiple foul is a situation in which two or more teammates commit personal fouls against the same opponent at approximately the same time. |
If he wasn't shooting, you cannot penalize both. If he was shooting, don't be the first crew in your area to call this.
|
Quote:
|
This case play doesn't matter, but another one, much less well defined, does matter.
|
Quote:
Why not? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The whistles were simultaneous. Why are they allowed to get together and decide which was first? |
Quote:
Rule 10-6 6. Multiple Foul: a. One free throw for each foul: (1) No try involved. (2) Successful or unsuccessful two-point try or tap. (3) Successful three-point try or tap. b. Two free throws for each foul: (1) Intentional or flagrant foul. (2) Unsuccessful three-point try or tap. Plus ball for throw-in if intentional or flagrant. NOTE: If one or both fouls of a multiple foul are flagrant, two free throws are awarded for each flagrant foul. Any player who commits a flagrant foul is disqualified. |
Quote:
(Give it up and find a new cause.) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
In the blarge situation that you're alluding to, it is one single act with two expressed judgments....neither of which could have possible occurred before the other AND such that neither official's judgement is allowed to override the other. :rolleyes: |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
NCAAM and NCAAW have the same woriding on double foul (and it's at least approximately the same as FED). Yet, one interprets it one way and one the other. Work to change it if you like. Write your state. Write the FED. Propose a rules clarification. etc. But please, please, please stop bringing it up here. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:57am. |