Whaddya got?

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Unfortunately, several people seem to be advocating applying their own personal philosophies to this play instead of enforcing the rules as written as the NFHS has instructed us to do several times over the past few years in POEs.

Just because one doesn't like the outcome that the rules generate, that doesn't permit an individual to apply them differently (some might even contend incorrectly).

Will you give us all a break. No one is even suggesting a personal interpretation at all. Actually there are several that are not trying to create a call out of fault logic. If your interpretation is so solid, then show some evidence that this situation should be called that way based on the circumstances of this play.

Peace