intentional vs flagrant

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett

As the saying goes, there's no substitute for experience. At least, that's what the sexy lady down on the corner tells me.

I'm guessing experience has made her less sexy.

[Ptflea2]

Thanks Snaqwells. Lets hope I don't have to call either in my men's league tonight.

[MathReferee]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

I'm guessing experience has made her less sexy.

I would have thought Padgett would have given this response to his own quote. Well played .

[Gargil]

It depends how you interpit the "spirit of the Rule"

[tref]

Originally Posted by Ptflea2

Thanks Snaqwells. Lets hope I don't have to call either in my men's league tonight.

Embrace the opportunity to handle these situations in the off-season should they arise. When they come up in sanctioned games, your experience will make you look as good as gold!

[Judtech]

Situation A: Team A is shooting the first of 2 FT's. B1 loudly passes gas. Would this be a 'fragrant foul'? What if A1 passed the gas, yet you couldn't hear it?
Sorry long day, and when I first looked at the post I actually thought it said "intentional vs FRAGRANT"

[Judtech]

Originally Posted by Gargil

It depends how you interpit the "spirit of the Rule"

If you were in Canada, you would embrace the "Spirit of the Radio". This is best exemplified by the three man crew of Lee, Peart and Lifeson!

[Mark Padgett]

Originally Posted by Judtech

Situation A: Team A is shooting the first of 2 FT's. B1 loudly passes gas. Would this be a 'fragrant foul'? What if A1 passed the gas, yet you couldn't hear it?
Sorry long day, and when I first looked at the post I actually thought it said "intentional vs FRAGRANT"

I can understand how you might have been confused. The other day, a friend of mine said he was using "innuendo", and I thought he meant an Italian suppository.

[DLH17]

Originally Posted by Judtech

Situation A: Team A is shooting the first of 2 FT's. B1 loudly passes gas. Would this be a 'fragrant foul'? What if A1 passed the gas, yet you couldn't hear it?
Sorry long day, and when I first looked at the post I actually thought it said "intentional vs FRAGRANT"

I understand you were being humorous, but, let's use this as an opp to point out what could be considered "coercion". If the noise didn't distract the shooter, I'm sure the change in odor gradient would.

[Judtech]

Originally Posted by DLH17

I understand you were being humorous, but, let's use this as an opp to point out what could be considered "coercion". If the noise didn't distract the shooter, I'm sure the change in odor gradient would.

Very good point. What would the reporting mechanic look like? Would you make a waving motion behind you or plug your nose? Are these mechanics different in NFHS, NCAA - M, NCAA - W and IAABO? Would the PA play the clip from Holy Grail "I fart in your general direction"?

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

1C is a live ball contact foul (such as your example.)
2B is a dead ball contact foul. Dead ball contact is to be ignored unless it is either intentional or flagrant. (I added 2C above)

Generally true, but not precisely correct. You are overlooking one aspect.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Generally true, but not precisely correct. You are overlooking one aspect.

airborne shooter

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

airborne shooter

Yep. So if a player intentionally fouls an airborne shooter after the ball has passed through the basket, what type of foul is correct using your classification list in this thread?

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Yep. So if a player intentionally fouls an airborne shooter after the ball has passed through the basket, what type of foul is correct using your classification list in this thread?

That would be a "stupid" foul.

[Altor]

Originally Posted by Ptflea2

Kinda hard to do when you don't have your rule book right?(which I stated in the first post)

You can download rulebooks in PDF format from the NFHS website if you have an NFHS ID number. At least in my state, all registered officials are also given NFHS ID numbers.

I also uploaded it to my iPod Touch, so I have it with me wherever. It's come in handy a few times.