something I've observed

[representing]

Originally Posted by fullor30

It's impossible to me based on your description to comment. What may have happened was she felt the foul and attempted to 'sell' an attempted shot with a late follow through after the whistle.

That could be possible... sorry for a not-so-good description.

Originally Posted by fullor30

If you were in locker room during my halftime and asked me 'why wasn't that a shooting foul' I wouldn't be happy

He wanted me to comment on the half so far, so I brought that up. I wouldn't have gone in and ask that without you saying something like that.

Originally Posted by fullor30

You sound like the coach for pete's sake.

Um, isn't that what this forum is for, to ask questions? Not like I was asking you to give me the square root of 428137011412022025.

Which, btw, is 654321795.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by representing

That could be possible... sorry for a not-so-good description.



He wanted me to comment on the half so far, so I brought that up. I wouldn't have gone in and ask that without you saying something like that.



Um, isn't that what this forum is for, to ask questions? Not like I was asking you to give me the square root of 428137011412022025.

Which, btw, is 654321795.

You left that part out. To me, you asked him an unsolicited question.

[ODJ]

The question to ask that official is would he had disallowed the basket if she somehow had made the shot?

[representing]

Originally Posted by ODJ

The question to ask that official is would he had disallowed the basket if she somehow had made the shot?

haha that is a good question, didn't think of that. I'm seeing him tomorrow I'll be sure to ask that

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by representing

He wanted me to comment on the half so far, so I brought that up.

Your question was legitimate. And the answer that you received was also legitimate. The official told you that in his opinion the player wasn't in the act of shooting. In his opinion, the player could have been in the act of passing instead.

Iow, it was a judgment call. And by inferring that he "messed up that call", all that you're doing now is questioning his judgment and saying that your judgment is better.