Overturning an OOB call

[Rich]

Working with my regular and favorite partner last night. 2-person, BV, the kind of game I'd take every day of the week.

We had an out of bounds call on the endline that my partner just missed. It was in my primary and he missed a tip. I was 100% sure he missed it, so I immediately hit the whistle "tweet, tweet, tweet" and went in to tell him what happened.

Instead, once I got to him, he simply blew his whistle and pointed the other way. I never said a word.

Frankly, it was just perfect. Why else would I come in? If I bothered coming in (and I've only done it twice this season) he knows why.

Night off. I think I may spend it going to a college basketball game.

[Indianaref]

Sounds like a great partnership. I appreciate it, if I get it wrong, that one of my partners comes in and we get it right, and vice versa.

[chartrusepengui]

My partner and I have gotten in the habit of pointing on an OOB and making eye contact for this reason. We've seen many officials that will whistle, be very quick in verbalizing a color and pointing.

Then, when you have a situation as described in the OP there is always more consternation if you change the call. If you just point and make eye contact with partner and make a change in direction without the immediate verbalization - you have far fewer problems.

[Rich]

Working 2-person, there's always a ball or two that shoots out on a sideline (or something) when the L is looking in at post play, etc.

My partner and I use body language all the time. If it goes out and I start up the floor, my partner (if he needs help) only needs to look at me and see me "going the other way" and knows to "go the other way." Likewise, if the ball is staying at the same end, I'll take a step or two towards that endline.

Subtle communication, but it gets used at least once or twice a game. I'd rather keep my eyes in the post, etc. and need help on these occasionally.

[bigwhistle]

The way we like to handle this situation is for the offiicial who is going to come and provide additional information to the calling official DOES NOT blow his whistle while coming to the calling official. If he blows his whistle he is drawing the attention of everyone in the gym to him, which makes it more difficult for the calling official to keep his own call IF HE MADE THE CALL FOR A REASON.

The calling official may have passed on a foul or some other action and awarded the ball to a team on purpose. We like to have the noncalling official come toward the calling official. If the calling official did what he did for a specific reason he will give the other official the stop sign, which turns that official around and returns him to his position. If the calling official allows the noncalling official to come to him, the call will almost always be changed BY THE CALLING OFFICIAL after receiving information he did not have or did not see.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by bigwhistle

The way we like to handle this situation is for the offiicial who is going to come and provide additional information to the calling official DOES NOT blow his whistle while coming to the calling official. If he blows his whistle he is drawing the attention of everyone in the gym to him, which makes it more difficult for the calling official to keep his own call IF HE MADE THE CALL FOR A REASON.

The calling official may have passed on a foul or some other action and awarded the ball to a team on purpose. We like to have the noncalling official come toward the calling official. If the calling official did what he did for a specific reason he will give the other official the stop sign, which turns that official around and returns him to his position. If the calling official allows the noncalling official to come to him, the call will almost always be changed BY THE CALLING OFFICIAL after receiving information he did not have or did not see.

Eh, I'm not fond of this. To each his own, I guess.

[KCRC]

Originally Posted by bigwhistle

The calling official may have passed on a foul or some other action and awarded the ball to a team on purpose.

Originally Posted by Clark Kent

I also would prefer he/she come to me just in case I passed on a foul (in this case there wasn't anything to pass on).

Newbie here. Actually prebie. I am considering an attempt to become an official in a couple of years, and thought I would use free time until that point to become as familiar with the rules as possible. This forum is helping a great deal in that regard.

Based on the above quotes, I am curious to get a rules reference for a situation I observed this past Saturday. Junior College game, NCAA rules. A1 controls a defensive rebound near the corner of endline and sideline in front of B's bench. B1 immediately picks up A1 in a full court man-to-man defense. B1 swipes at ball (looked like maybe a foul but maybe not) and causes A1 to lose possession, after which the ball clearly (from where I was sitting) goes off A1's knee and out of bounds on the sideline. T blows whistle and signals Team A's ball and spot throw-in on sideline. B's bench goes crazy. B's coach stands up and yells to T that the ball went off A1's knee. T says something to B's coach in an attempt at an explanation. B's coach then immediately yells, "then call a foul, you just can't give them the ball if it went off her leg." T ignores B's coach, administers the throw-in and the game proceeds without further incident.

Does anyone have a rules reference or explanation for the practice of "passing on a foul" and awarding the ball to the team that touched it last before going out of bounds? If this has been discussed before, I apologize, I couldn't find anything using the search function. Thanks for the help.

[GoodwillRef]

Originally Posted by bigwhistle

The way we like to handle this situation is for the offiicial who is going to come and provide additional information to the calling official DOES NOT blow his whistle while coming to the calling official. If he blows his whistle he is drawing the attention of everyone in the gym to him, which makes it more difficult for the calling official to keep his own call IF HE MADE THE CALL FOR A REASON.

The calling official may have passed on a foul or some other action and awarded the ball to a team on purpose. We like to have the noncalling official come toward the calling official. If the calling official did what he did for a specific reason he will give the other official the stop sign, which turns that official around and returns him to his position. If the calling official allows the noncalling official to come to him, the call will almost always be changed BY THE CALLING OFFICIAL after receiving information he did not have or did not see.

Why do we have some many different ways to cover a simple procedure…blow your whistle and come offer the information you have...if you partner wants to change his/her call fine...if not fine. By not blowing your whistle both teams may already be at the other end of the floor and then your partner overturns his call and we have to gather up all 10 players and bring them back down to the right end of the court. Giving your partner the "stop sign" can give the appearance that you are not working as a team and that you are unapproachable.

[fiasco]

Originally Posted by RichMSN

Working 2-person, there's always a ball or two that shoots out on a sideline (or something) when the L is looking in at post play, etc.

This has happened to me several times this year, so I've included this specific tidbit in my pregame and it's helped out a lot (with the partners who actually listen during pre-game ).

[BillyMac]

For out-of-bounds help, let's get it right. Come together for a change if needed. If I have no idea and I look to
you for help, just give a directional signal. No need to come to me. Just point. If you don't know, give me
a jump ball signal. If I signal but I get it wrong then blow the whistle and come to me. Tell me what you
saw and let me decide if I’m going to change it.