Welmer out...

[tomegun]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

1) No, and if I ever get the urge to sit down and break down any NCAA official on tape(other than somebody I may know, like and think will appreciate it if I do give him some constructive feedback), I'm going to take something to make the urge go away. Why would I want to waste my time looking for reasons to say to the world that so-and-so is a crappy official? I'll leave that up to you, Tom. I always thought that evaluation by tape was supposed to be a positive process, not an excuse for someone to put down a fellow official. Somehow, I get the idea that your breaking Welmer down on tape might be done a little bit too subjectively.

I haven't looked at tape of Welmer. However, after attending several camps and watching tape with my friends it doesn't take a lot of time to tell when someone is officiating by the seat of their pants and when someone has a tried and true method of getting plays right.

Sorry if I'm not willing to drink the Welmer Kool-Aid. I will leave that to you.