Establishing confidence, confidence and respect from coaches and players

[gslefeb]

Bob, yes.. I was trying to imply that the contact was great enough to warrent a foul..if all other factors hold.

I understand first there is contact, then there is judgement as to whether the contact is a foul, the judgement takes into account the adv / disadv, etc...I'm trying to discuss.

So yes, it should be B1 contacts A1, given what follows - would you call a foul?

Correct?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by gslefeb

Bob, yes.. I was trying to imply that the contact was great enough to warrent a foul..if all other factors hold.

And that "if all other factors hold" is ad/disad and/or judgment. So, it can't possibly be answered.

[JRutledge]

gslefeb,

The problem with your example is you assume that what we have been talking about here is passing on illegal contact. I do not recall that anyone said to pass on illegal contact. But to have illegal contact you must have some kind of disadvantage to the player being contacted. And the rules clearly express this position. I would never knowingly pass on illegal contact. I might pass on contact I deem incidental and that is comes with judgment and experience. And this is all that anyone here has really said. No one has advocated not calling a foul when necessarily. We just want to make sure that there is an actual foul.

Peace