Block/Charge on Dunk

[Texref]

Ok, I know that one picture doesn't tell the whole story. I was watching this game last night and had the exact angle that the photographer and the lead had on this play.

(hopefully this image posts)

Link for photo just in case it doesn't show up: http://www.meangreensports.com//shar...IMAGE_SIZE=400

The defender was established prior to the dunker going airborne. The defense was set just above the low block along the lane, but outside of it, so it in no way was in the restricted area (which I know is not in college, but also to say that he wasn't under the basket)

I see this type of play a lot in the men's game. Is there any reason why the officials are no calling this play. I was talking to another official shortly after the play happened and him and I both thought it should have been whistled as player control. Now, I'm not a fanboy and neither is he as he actually works for the white team. Just asking.

Also, immediately after the dunk, the white player stood over the blue player and said something to him. No T was called. Doesn't relate to the play I'm asking about though.

This was a first round conference tournament game.

[Scrapper1]

There are so many things that you can't tell from a a still photo. But IF the defender was at the spot before the shooter went airborne and IF he didn't move laterally or forward while the shooter was airborne, then I think it looks like a pretty clear PC foul.

Maybe the official thought the contact was not squarely in the torso, like the shooter was going past the defender laterally. But from the photo alone, I would agree that it looks like a PC.

[Raymond]

I'll just say I haven't seen many (if any) PC calls in the NCAA basketball when a player finishes the play with a dunk. I have seen a couple of "over the backs" nullify tip slams.

May be one of those unwritten rules of college basketball. (You know, like the unwritten 2-step rule applied to NBA travelling)

[Texref]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I'll just say I haven't seen many (if any) PC calls in the NCAA basketball when a player finishes the play with a dunk. I have seen a couple of "over the backs" nullify tip slams.

May be one of those unwritten rules of college basketball. (You know, like the unwritten 2-step rule applied to NBA travelling)

That is kind of what I was thinking. Just asking to see if I'm the only one that is noticing? Oh well.

[grunewar]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I'll just say I haven't seen many (if any) PC calls in the NCAA basketball when a player finishes the play with a dunk.

Like it or not, I agree with this statement.

[DonInKansas]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

(You know, like the unwritten 2-step rule applied to NBA travelling)

Like the crab dribble?