Block/Charge on Dunk

[Scrapper1]

There are so many things that you can't tell from a a still photo. But IF the defender was at the spot before the shooter went airborne and IF he didn't move laterally or forward while the shooter was airborne, then I think it looks like a pretty clear PC foul.

Maybe the official thought the contact was not squarely in the torso, like the shooter was going past the defender laterally. But from the photo alone, I would agree that it looks like a PC.

[Raymond]

I'll just say I haven't seen many (if any) PC calls in the NCAA basketball when a player finishes the play with a dunk. I have seen a couple of "over the backs" nullify tip slams.

May be one of those unwritten rules of college basketball. (You know, like the unwritten 2-step rule applied to NBA travelling)

[Texref]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I'll just say I haven't seen many (if any) PC calls in the NCAA basketball when a player finishes the play with a dunk. I have seen a couple of "over the backs" nullify tip slams.

May be one of those unwritten rules of college basketball. (You know, like the unwritten 2-step rule applied to NBA travelling)

That is kind of what I was thinking. Just asking to see if I'm the only one that is noticing? Oh well.

[grunewar]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I'll just say I haven't seen many (if any) PC calls in the NCAA basketball when a player finishes the play with a dunk.

Like it or not, I agree with this statement.

[DonInKansas]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

(You know, like the unwritten 2-step rule applied to NBA travelling)

Like the crab dribble?