Illinois/ Northwestern

[M&M Guy]

Originally Posted by fullor30

I was thinking to myself, would I do the same? Maybe, maybe not.

We pre-game this all the time. If one official doesn't know what direction to call and asks for help, the other official(s) will simply signal the direction and away we go. If an official does signal a direction, but one of the other officials is 100% they saw it wrong (or 116%, 123%, whatever...), then that official will go to the calling official and give them that information. That allows the calling official to correct their call. I have even gone so far as to tell my partners, "If you're coming to me with information, I'm probably changing my call even before you get to me", due to the fact I trust that my partner is sure of his/her information.

That's probably what happened here; Jamie was sure that Phil might've been too close and didn't see the whole play, so he came in with the info. Phil's probably saying "thanks" because he was probably the only one that didn't see it correctly.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by M&M Guy

We pre-game this all the time. If one official doesn't know what direction to call and asks for help, the other official(s) will simply signal the direction and away we go. If an official does signal a direction, but one of the other officials is 100% they saw it wrong (or 116%, 123%, whatever...), then that official will go to the calling official and give them that information. That allows the calling official to correct their call. I have even gone so far as to tell my partners, "If you're coming to me with information, I'm probably changing my call even before you get to me", due to the fact I trust that my partner is sure of his/her information.

That's probably what happened here; Jamie was sure that Phil might've been too close and didn't see the whole play, so he came in with the info. Phil's probably saying "thanks" because he was probably the only one that didn't see it correctly.

Yup...........three pros working as one.

[BubbaRef]

I always try to pre-game that if I come to you or you come to me, then the call has to be changed, if not, move on with the game. So if you dont know 100% get the clock stopped and ask and dont guess.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by BubbaRef

I always try to pre-game that if I come to you or you come to me, then the call has to be changed, if not, move on with the game. So if you dont know 100% get the clock stopped and ask and dont guess.

I'm not going to go that far.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by BubbaRef

I always try to pre-game that if I come to you or you come to me, then the call has to be changed, if not, move on with the game. So if you dont know 100% get the clock stopped and ask and dont guess.

Originally Posted by fullor30

I'm not going to go that far.

Same here. I had a play where I was the Lead and clearly saw who caused the OOB on a rebound. C headed my way but I gave him a look to let him know not to come. At halftime the Crew Chief, who was T on the play, says he was glad that the C never made it to me.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Same here. I had a play where I was the Lead and clearly saw who caused the OOB on a rebound. C headed my way but I gave him a look to let him know not to come. At halftime the Crew Chief, who was T on the play, says he was glad that the C never made it to me.

I think you need to be 200% sure.

Years ago I had a sophomore boys game and as new trail, ball gets knocked OB right in front of me, I couldn't be more positive. new lead who is almost at half court toots and comes in with his 'knowledge' I stick with my call. At half he says I'm not a good partner, that if he comes in I should change it.

He happens to be a good official and we are freindly, but I always remember that situation.

[M&M Guy]

Originally Posted by BubbaRef

I always try to pre-game that if I come to you or you come to me, then the call has to be changed, if not, move on with the game. So if you dont know 100% get the clock stopped and ask and dont guess.

I would use this as a good philosophy to follow, so that the official coming in is sure about their information. However, I agree with fullor30 to an extent in that I wouldn't call it an absolute. I have seen an example where the pass gets tipped up top by white, goes OOB along the endline, the L signals for white ball, the crowd goes crazy, and partner comes in with the info that white did indeed tip it out by the 3-point line. However, what the L saw was blue tried to save it right before it went OOB, and was the last to tip it. L steps out and says, "Thank you for the info, but blue 21 tipped it right here, that's why we're staying with white". This situation allows the L to stay with the call if indeed they have info that might be different from their partners' info.

For the most part, if I'm receiving info from my partner, I agree I'm trusting their info and going with the correction.

[BubbaRef]

Originally Posted by M&M Guy

I would use this as a good philosophy to follow, so that the official coming in is sure about their information. However, I agree with fullor30 to an extent in that I wouldn't call it an absolute. I have seen an example where the pass gets tipped up top by white, goes OOB along the endline, the L signals for white ball, the crowd goes crazy, and partner comes in with the info that white did indeed tip it out by the 3-point line. However, what the L saw was blue tried to save it right before it went OOB, and was the last to tip it. L steps out and says, "Thank you for the info, but blue 21 tipped it right here, that's why we're staying with white". This situation allows the L to stay with the call if indeed they have info that might be different from their partners' info.

For the most part, if I'm receiving info from my partner, I agree I'm trusting their info and going with the correction.

I guess I should have said it this way...

[M&M Guy]

Originally Posted by BubbaRef

I guess I should have said it this way...

I knew what you meant.

[GoodwillRef]

Were we watching the same game? Hillary can't run at all, it hurts me to watch him run.