Intentional, Personal, or Common?

[Da Official]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Why are you having doubts?

I wanted to get confirmation because the official who asked me the question (my partner last night) said he was watching his son's game and Scenario 1 occured and the officials working the game called a common foul. A well respected official who was there evaluating the game officials told them after the game that it should have been an intentional foul. The offical who asked me the question also thought it should have been intentional but wanted my opinion. I told him based on my understanding of the ball being "live" and the contact was not an attempt to neutralize an advantage or stop the clock from starting the officials made the right call. I told him however I would check the rules and see if any cases existed. When I didn't find a case I figured I would ask the boards to be sure.

Thanks guys!

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Da Official

I wanted to get confirmation because the official who asked me the question (my partner last night) said he was watching his son's game and Scenario 1 occured and the officials working the game called a common foul. A well respected official who was there evaluating the game officials told them after the game that it should have been an intentional foul. The offical who asked me the question also thought it should have been intentional but wanted my opinion. I told him based on my understanding of the ball being "live" and the contact was not an attempt to neutralize an advantage or stop the clock from starting the officials made the right call. I told him however I would check the rules and see if any cases existed. When I didn't find a case I figured I would ask the boards to be sure.

Thanks guys!

I'd like to know their basis for saying it should have been intentional.

They thought it was a dead ball foul.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Ch1town

They thought it was a dead ball foul.

Ouch.

[fiasco]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Ouch.

Seriously. I feel bad for the officials being evaluated.

[Back In The Saddle]

In 2 I might not have any foul at all. See the rules on screening and incidental contact.

[rockyroad]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

I'd like to know their basis for saying it should have been intentional.

Why couldn't it be Intentional? I've seen some screening action called Intentional before - the screener went for the head with a forearm, etc...I would hope that the evaluator wasn't talking about the dead ball scenario , but screening action certainly could be Intentional.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by rockyroad

Why couldn't it be Intentional? I've seen some screening action called Intentional before - the screener went for the head with a forearm, etc...I would hope that the evaluator wasn't talking about the dead ball scenario , but screening action certainly could be Intentional.

That's why I was asking.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Da Official

I wanted to get confirmation because the official who asked me the question (my partner last night) said he was watching his son's game and Scenario 1 occured and the officials working the game called a common foul. A well respected official who was there evaluating the game officials told them after the game that it should have been an intentional foul.

It might have been intentional, depending on what happened. It would have been an Intentional Personal foul, not an Intentional Technical foul. OR, as you suggest, it could have been (most likely would have been) a Common Personal foul.

The title of your post makes it seem as though you think there are three choices -- there are only two.