Have you ever...

[CoachP]

Originally Posted by fiasco

....called or emailed a coach to tell them you kicked a call?

I was thinking about a game I did last year and started wondering if I should have done this after I figured out my mistake.

Putting myself in JV Coach A's shoes here:

1) I'd rather get a phone call over an email.
2) If I knew I was going to see him again (and I looked up to verify I was right) I'd wait till then to tell him.
3) If I found out I was right and wasn't going to see him again, I'd probably just forget about it as I got my satisfaction. If he calls the school and admits it, that would just be more icing.
4) If it was a buzzer beater, down by one point, shot that was just disallowed, I would have the AD notify the assignor so he can POE it at his next meeting!



Now, for further thought, lets say it was sitch 4 above and my VARSITY game. Are you guys still turned off if I pull out my rule book?

[M&M Guy]

Originally Posted by CoachP

Now, for further thought, lets say it was sitch 4 above and my VARSITY game. Are you guys still turned off if I pull out my rule book?

Yep. I think the problem with that is everyone can see what you're doing, and all it does is show up the official. In fact, it pretty easily falls under the penalty for 10-4-1(b), and, depending on the crowd reaction, 10-4-1(f). (Since you apparently have one those rule book-thingies, you know what I'm referencing. )

I know, for the most part, you just want to make things right, but bringing out the rule book during the game will not work. If you want to discuss a rule after the game, at the local watering hole, in a friendly manner, I have no problem with that. I don't like it if I screw up a rule, and I venture to say almost all us would feel the same. But we will not have that type of discussion during the game.

Along those same lines, have you ever gone up to a ref after a game and apologized for using the wrong strategy at the end of a game, and it caused an overtime? How would you feel if an official came up to you during the game with a Dean Smith or Bob Knight book to point out what you're doing is wrong? Same therory - good discussion well before or after a game, just not during.