Please help clarify - 'half step' rule

[Dan_ref]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

Whoa! Whoa! Whoa!!! We were talking about a particular play that was described by BNR, which was a 1-on-0 breakaway dunk. In that situation, there's no defense to referee, so I'm going to let my partner make that call in his/her primary.

And being a Presidential election year, I made sure to say that I "might" not make it from the C. If it's an obvious travel from the 3-point line (like Jurassic mentioned in another thread), then I would think somebody would have to make it, even if it makes the primary official look bad.

Well, IMO you're on that slippery slope and trying to hold on.

In my exchange with you I NEVER qualified the play as a 1 - 0 breakaway dunk.

All I asked was do you routinely pass on step step dunk.

You said no but you won't reach out of your primary to take it.

I can understand if you want to go back & reframe the discussion.