help with a Tech call from Refs NFHS rules

[rainmaker]

Originally Posted by gmund1948

The tournament director told us that we were only
allowed on assistant. We discussed the lack of such a rule in the Bylaws.

So did this discrepancy get straightened out? The director thought only one assistant was allowed, although you didn't see it in the written rules. Still, perhaps that played a part in the ruling?

I can't see that filing a protest will change anything. There's almost no league that will change the outcome of a game based on a protest filed by a losing team. And really, how much difference could it make to lose one assistant, if the head coach and the other assistant (you) would handle it correctly?

[gmund1948]

Originally Posted by rainmaker

So did this discrepancy get straightened out? The director thought only one assistant was allowed, although you didn't see it in the written rules. Still, perhaps that played a part in the ruling?

I can't see that filing a protest will change anything. There's almost no league that will change the outcome of a game based on a protest filed by a losing team. And really, how much difference could it make to lose one assistant, if the head coach and the other assistant (you) would handle it correctly?

Thanks you are correct, The bylaws allow for the protest to be reviewed and
if a mistake was made, the "Second place Team could be allowed to move forward to the regional tournament without being seeded.

Thats the reason I posted for clarification.

BTW I miss Oregon

[rainmaker]

Originally Posted by gmund1948

Thanks you are correct, The bylaws allow for the protest to be reviewed and
if a mistake was made, the "Second place Team could be allowed to move forward to the regional tournament without being seeded.

Thats the reason I posted for clarification.

BTW I miss Oregon

1. Your league needs to get rid of that "review of protest" rule. No way a rec league should be even listening to protests.

2. And can you seriously be saying that having your other assistant coach tossed merits an overturn of the outcome of the game?!?

3. You are way, way too legalistic about the rules. Reffing is much more about art and judgment than the letter of the law. Just because one ref was too touchy about some comments, and called a T that another ref wouldn't have, doesn't mean you got robbed. There's no such hard and fast rules out there.

[Mark Padgett]

Originally Posted by gmund1948

BTW I miss Oregon

You were Miss Oregon! What year?

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett

You were Miss Oregon! What year?

Miss Oregon 2007



She reminds me of Sarah Cahlke, who plays Dr. Elliot Reid on "Scrubs".

[Mark Dexter]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Miss Oregon 2007

Except they spelled Juulie's name wrong!

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Mark Dexter

Except they spelled Juulie's name wrong!

Good one. I bet Mark Padgett wished he had come up with that one.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Miss Oregon 2007


She reminds me of Sarah Cahlke, who plays Dr. Elliot Reid on "Scrubs".

The girl who played Roseanne's oldest daughter for a while?