Goal Tending

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by Gimlet25id

#1 - Pretty sure I have a good handle on the BI/GT requirements.

#2 - After looking up the word cylinder I realize You & Bob are absolutely correct in the fact that ,"basket" & "cylinder," means two different things. Ring, cylinder, I thought they were the same. Now I know!

Doesn't #2 pretty much make #1 a false statement?

[Gimlet25id]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

Doesn't #2 pretty much make #1 a false statement?

Well I guess it would seem so. The way I would rule BI would be the same. Like I said I wrongly (for the third time) assumed cylinder & basket were considered the same thing. Thinking imaginary cylinder was the space above the rim and cylinder was the rim or the same as the rim.

I thought a ball inside of the ring could also be considered inside of the cylinder, which by definition would be wrong as Bob & JR stated earlier.

Regardless if I was calling the rim the cylinder or the rim it wouldn't change how I will look @ the play. However this discussion will/has changed the way I will define BI.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

Doesn't #2 pretty much make #1 a false statement?

Not neccessarily.

I can believe he knows when it needs to be call but not how to put it into the proper words.