NFHS exam part 1 question #34

[bcooley66]

I believe the answer is true. Refer to Case Book 7.5.1 and the comment that follows.

[inigo montoya]

I'm missing something. I've only just started my 2nd year officiating so I'm just trying to make sure I understand.

Team A's throw-in following a timeout. A is not ready for play, official places the ball on the floor and gives a 5-count. Whistle, violation on A. Now Team B's throw-in. This is according to the RPP.

Future throw in for Team A. A does not make a thrower available. Official places the ball on the floor and gives a 5-count. According to 7-5-1c this isn't this a T? So when the question says "a violation in one situation does not carry over to another" why isn't the answer false? Doesn't the previous violation carry over, therefore B is shooting 2 for the Technical?

[Adam]

No, this is not a T later in the game. It's only a T if they do it again during the initial RPP procedure.

Once everyone starts playing again, the RPP will start over next time it's used.

[inigo montoya]

I guess I don't like the wording of 7-5-1c, then... "if that team continues to delay when authorized to make a throw-in"

Even w/ the ""in each situation" in 7-5-1 it's a poor choice of semantics. It wouldn't have been terribly difficult to make the rule clearer.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by inigo montoya

I guess I don't like the wording of 7-5-1c, then... "if that team continues to delay when authorized to make a throw-in"

Even w/ the ""in each situation" in 7-5-1 it's a poor choice of semantics. It wouldn't have been terribly difficult to make the rule clearer.

"Continue" means an uninterrupted time span....in the same way that continuous motion is defined and used.

[IREFU2]

Originally Posted by inigo montoya

I'm missing something. I've only just started my 2nd year officiating so I'm just trying to make sure I understand.

Team A's throw-in following a timeout. A is not ready for play, official places the ball on the floor and gives a 5-count. Whistle, violation on A. Now Team B's throw-in. This is according to the RPP.

Future throw in for Team A. A does not make a thrower available. Official places the ball on the floor and gives a 5-count. According to 7-5-1c this isn't this a T? So when the question says "a violation in one situation does not carry over to another" why isn't the answer false? Doesn't the previous violation carry over, therefore B is shooting 2 for the Technical?

I was thinking the same.....but I guess other dont think so.