Spot Throw-in

[Adam]

Had an AAU coach try to start an argument on this with me once.

Most coaches know the rule, though, and if you'd called it chances are you'd have had an even bigger problem on your hands with the other coach.

Part of the problem is the mechanic some officials use when calling the spot violation.

[jdw3018]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Part of the problem is the mechanic some officials use when calling the spot violation.

Exactly...many officials use the traveling mechanic to call this violation. Not sure where that came from - perhaps it was that way long ago?

[Splute]

While we are still doing scrimmages, do you recommend we mention this after the game to the coach or just leave it be? None of us addressed the coach; just played on.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Splute

While we are still doing scrimmages, do you recommend we mention this after the game to the coach or just leave it be? None of us addressed the coach; just played on.

Ignore it if you can. If the coach is adament that you got the rule wrong, a discussion isn't going to help; and I do not recommend pulling the rule book out and showing him the "traveling and pivot foot rules do not apply during a throwin" part.

If he asks you politely after he calms down, discuss it with him. I wouldn't, however, recommend initiating the conversation either during or after the game.

[Splute]

Okay... nothing came of it. No questions to us or otherwise. Perhaps it was a ploy to see if we would bite. It certainly made me think for a minute.
Our chapter had a meeting with the Varsity coaches this year to discuss and explain many of these rules. The coaches that DID attend said they really learned something and wished ALL the coaches had shown up. They also had an opportunity to share what they would like to see from Officials. Of course the main concern on their part was that officials are not consistent in their calls.....

[blindzebra]

Real simple rule of thumb for a spot throw-in:

If a thrower takes a big step to the side and crosses over with the other foot, violation.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by jdw3018

Exactly...many officials use the traveling mechanic to call this violation. Not sure where that came from - perhaps it was that way long ago?

Sometimes...but I've seen officials call a "travel" when the player in no way moved anywhere near 3' but just shuffled their feet. Some officials just get it wrong.

[jdw3018]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Sometimes...but I've seen officials call a "travel" when the player in no way moved anywhere near 3' but just shuffled their feet. Some officials just get it wrong.

Certainly, though I was just responding from a "got the call right but used the wrong mechanic" point of view, which perpetuates the myth that the inbounder must maintain a pivot foot and/or that leaving that spot is a traveling violation.