![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Nice. I prefer to interpret it as "or". It's not hard. |
Quote:
If you have a double foul in the key after the throw-in has been released but before it is touched(like the current situation), where is the POI? |
Quote:
Sorry that you don't agree, but you are going to be in the minority on that one. |
Quote:
Where in the original post is there a foul of any type? |
Quote:
Would the throw-in spot be any different in the 2 scenarios? (Mine or the original) |
Quote:
Why? -- because a double foul DURING a throw-in is clearly one of the items listed in 4-36-1 that invokes the POI rule. Ball location doesn't matter if the double foul happened DURING the throw-in because 4-36-2b doesn't say to go to the location of the ball, only 4-36-2a does. For part b the POI is the throw-in. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
What else can we do? How about we take a look at the definition of when a throw-in ends??? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
1. Even though this is a debate between 2 people your interpretation is that one of us in in the minority. Is it possible to be promoted from King of Bullsh1t Interpretations to something higher? Emperor? Need to look into that. 2. If they meant it your way simply inserting the word "either" would have made it clear. Example: A1 is standing OOB when the ball bounces off his hands and lands OOB on the other sideline (let's assume A1 is Chuck). Where's the throw-in spot? Where it last touched the player or where it most recently touched either the player or the floor? |
Quote:
One whistle is for a foul. The other is to fix a clock error. Completely different scenarios. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:35pm. |