Foul on Shooter then PC

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

We basically agree, and I don't think that Juggling Referee's philosophy is really that much different either. I just didn't think that, either way, you could really make a blanket statement using "always" or "never".

It doesn't happen often, as you said. But I can see a very specific situation where the false double foul might be the right call.

For me I can say "always" or "never" in this situation. If others want to call this that is there right to do so. They do have the rulebook and casebook to back them up. I just think this is worst than calling a blarge because at least a blarge is an accident. In my opinion you basically have to insist on calling this and stick with a false double foul. Be my guest.

Peace

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by sharkref

No, if he or she was knocked into the third row, then that would fall under flagrant and should be called but if A1 is fouled on the way up and the other contact is strictly momentum, I would only call the shooting foul. I respect any other opinion and I would also say calling a false double foul would not be wrong either.

Didn't you just say two completely different things here?

You're stating that calling a false double foul is wrong, but calling a false double foul isn't wrong.

Momentum really can't be a factor. Once he leaves his feet, the shooter's momentum isn't going to be altered that much. The path of his momentum might be altered though.

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

For me I can say "always" or "never" in this situation. If others want to call this that is there right to do so. They do have the rulebook and casebook to back them up. I just think this is worst than calling a blarge because at least a blarge is an accident. In my opinion you basically have to insist on calling this and stick with a false double foul. Be my guest.

I was wrong. We don't agree then.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

I was wrong. We don't agree then.

I can live with that. It is not going to change my position or my thoughts on this.

Peace

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

I was wrong. We don't agree then.

JRut and Jurassic disagreeing on something. Who would have thunk it?