What did the crew miss?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by mplagrow

What do you mean? Are you suggesting to call something because the player admitted it?

While I probably would not call something because a player admitted it (and definitely wouldn't in this situation), I would use the opportunity to explain to the player that we missed it, but that it was against the rules, and that s/he shouldn't do it again.

[jontheref]

Can I get in on this....I had not necessarily this same sitch, but, I had a guy in a jv game actually do a pullup on the rim. I only penalized the infraction but not the T but now I am wondering whether I should have done both?

[armymanjones]

Originally Posted by jontheref

Can I get in on this....I had not necessarily this same sitch, but, I had a guy in a jv game actually do a pullup on the rim. I only penalized the infraction but not the T but now I am wondering whether I should have done both?

The situation you described seems to me if he wasn't holding on to avoid injury it should have been a T.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by jontheref

Can I get in on this....I had not necessarily this same sitch, but, I had a guy in a jv game actually do a pullup on the rim. I only penalized the infraction but not the T but now I am wondering whether I should have done both?

A pull-up on the rim is a T. What is the infraction to which you are referring?

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

A pull-up on the rim is a T. What is the infraction to which you are referring?

BI

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

BI

He didn't describe the play. He could have done a pull-up after mis-timing a rebound.

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

He didn't describe the play. He could have done a pull-up after mis-timing a rebound.

And then what infraction would he have called, besides the T?

This whole thread has been about BI and grasping the rim. He said he called the infraction, but not the T. By process of elimination. . .

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

And then what infraction would he have called, besides the T?

This whole thread has been about BI and grasping the rim. He said he called the infraction, but not the T. By process of elimination. . .

Or he could have kicked a rule concerning BI as someone did in another thread.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by jontheref

Can I get in on this....I had not necessarily this same sitch, but, I had a guy in a jv game actually do a pullup on the rim. I only penalized the infraction but not the T but now I am wondering whether I should have done both?

If it was BI, then you should have called both. This is per casebook play something.something.something, situation something.