10 seconds

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by budjones05

My rules meeting this year in the state i live in allows protests if they are reasonable

What state?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

What state?

And who defines reasonable? And is the meaning of "protest" stop the game and look up the rule? Who looks it up? Ho wmuch time can be taken? What happens if the coach reads the rule one way and the official another?

[mplagrow]

Originally Posted by budjones05

My rules meeting this year in the state i live in allows protests if they are reasonable

That's got to be an SEC state.

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by mplagrow

That's got to be an SEC state.

No, no no, no.....

The proper statement is "That's got to be a......wait for it......SEC state".

[mplagrow]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

No, no no, no.....

The proper statement is "That's got to be a......wait for it......SEC state".

Oops. . .poor mechanics on my part. It's been a while since I pulled that one out of the bag!

[Nevadaref]

Actually, the state of Missouri has a protest of this nature in soccer.

The coach must notify the referee before play is restarted that he is protesting that the rules of the game are not being followed or applied properly and then has ten minutes to produce a rules book and prove his case.



Don't shoot the messenger!

[refnrev]

[QUOTE=Nevadaref]Actually, the state of Missouri has a protest of this nature in soccer.

The coach must notify the referee before play is restarted that he is protesting that the rules of the game are not being followed or applied properly and then has ten minutes to produce a rules book and prove his case.
____________________________________

Are you sure about this one?

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by tjones1

There are no protests. 5-4-2

There's no protest but coaches 'protest' calls all the time. If a coach wants to use a timeout to look up a rule concerning a call you just made, so be it.

protest - an expression or declaration of objection, disapproval, or dissent, often in opposition to something a person is powerless to prevent or avoid. That last part's pretty funny!

[Kelvin green]

You stopped a game to pull out a rule book and look up the rule in the book?

You are setting up a dangerous precedent and will get you in trouble. If the state allows a protest tell him to write it down and file it with the state.

[budjones05]

im from missouri

[Kelvin green]

Ironic

From the "Show me State"

[mplagrow]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Actually, the state of Missouri has a protest of this nature in soccer.

The coach must notify the referee before play is restarted that he is protesting that the rules of the game are not being followed or applied properly and then has ten minutes to produce a rules book and prove his case.


Don't shoot the messenger!

Absolutely insane! Is there a limit to how many times this can happen in a game? Is there any consequence for the coach being wrong, which he almost inevitably will be? I'd suggest a finger. Once the coach is out of those, no more protests (unless he wants to offer another part of his anatomy. . .).

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by refnrev

Are you sure about this one?

That info is according to Mel on the NFHS forum. He refs in Missouri. I believe him.

[budjones05]

Originally Posted by mplagrow

Absolutely insane! Is there a limit to how many times this can happen in a game? Is there any consequence for the coach being wrong, which he almost inevitably will be? I'd suggest a finger. Once the coach is out of those, no more protests (unless he wants to offer another part of his anatomy. . .).

They can call a time-out. If they are wrong, they lose the time out

[Adam]

And if they're right, they keep the timeout? Sorta like instant replay?