|
|||
Illegal Substitution
We had a long discussion on this at our last association meeting. A1 is at the line shooting free throws. B1 comes to the table to report and comes out on the court without being beckoned by the official. In this case the T (three person mechanics) is responsible for beckoning (IAW our state manual) and is right by the table. He did not see the player coming to the table so could not stop him. Anyway, Coach of A starts telling the T he MUST call a technical for an illegal substitution. The T, new to our association but not as an official, calls the T for the illegal sub. Many of our officials did not agree that this was the correct call. Many of our veterans said that we must enforce good game management and not let this happen. Also, if it happens we should not call a T just because a coach tells us to. Most thought he was testing an official new to the area. Options discussed were to just ignore the coach and tell B2 to get back to the table, blame it on the clock operator or scorekkeper and tell the sub to come back, just tell the coach no T and fix the problem or go and talk to the C (about anything at all) and then come back and tell the coach the C beckoned him in so it is legal. What does folks here say? I am in agreement with our veterans that we should do all we can to avoid these kinds of situations but once it happens and the coach clearly is correct in telling you how to interperet the ruling, what do you do? This was in a close game and the T did change the flow of the game.
|
|
|||
I would not assess the T, especially if this was the first time in the game that there was a problem like this. It's easy to fix - "Son, go back to the table and wait til the first FT is shot and I beckon you into the game"...
The T is not always the best resolution to problems. As for the complaining coach, I'd say - "Coach, I've got two choices here: penalize for an infraction that has no impact on the game, or do the right thing and send him back to the table. I'm going to do the right thing. You may not like it now, but you definitely would if the shoe were on the other foot." Others may disagree, but that's how I'd handle it. |
|
|||
Thats why its always good to have a pregame with the table and make sure they understand "not" to let any subs in until an official tells them to come on the court. Now, if the person just ran off the bench and onto the court, then I would possibly look at other options! Some body, whether its the C or T should have seen that kid on his way to the table and then the button hook into the game.
__________________
Score the Basket!!!! |
|
|||
The wording in the book says, "Penalized if discovered before the ball becomes live."
This is one of those situations where a lot of judgment is needed. Lots of refs will let this go unless it gets to be a problem during that game, but it is technically agains the rules. You as the ref need to keep a lot of different things in mind, such as what the generally accepted procedures are in your area, and how other refs in your association or group will handle this. YOu don't want to be the only one who enforces it, and you don't want to be the only one who lets it go. There's not one right answer for every situation, even though the rule is absolute. |
|
|||
The coach is clearly right. The Trail handled it correctly. This is a plainly written rule and there is no reason that it shouldn't be enforced. At the HS level, the players and coaches are expected to know this.
RULE 10, SECTION 2 SUBSTITUTE TECHNICAL A substitute shall not enter the court: ART. 1 . . . Without reporting to the scorer. ART. 2 . . . Without being beckoned by an official, except between quarters. PENALTY: (Section 2) Two free throws plus ball for division-line throw-in. One foul for either or both requirements. Penalized if discovered before the ball becomes live. NOTE: A single flagrant technical foul or the second technical foul charged to a substitute results in disqualification of the offender to the team bench. |
|
|||
If you want to be a rulebook official, go ahead and call that. If you want to use good common sense, get the player to go back to the table if this is an honest mistake. Kids do silly things and the kid might have been nervous. I could call a T every single game if I really wanted to for this infraction. Unless the kid ran all the way across the court, do not call a T for this.
Peace
__________________
Let us get into "Good Trouble." ----------------------------------------------------------- Charles Michael “Mick” Chambers (1947-2010) |
|
|||
Quote:
JRut, Thanks. I like this. I would not call a T here and will be more aware of it in the future. |
|
|||
Quote:
Quote:
|
|
|||
If you want to be known as a referee who doesn't enforce the rules properly, then don't make that call. If you want to follow your own personal philosophy and think that you know better then the members of the NFHS committee then send the kid back to the table and do nothing about it. Rules enforcement is only POE #5 this season.
|
|
|||
I do not understand why we must use the letter of the law in this case, but in the thread of timeouts, there is all talk about using common sense. I guess some people like to pick and choose when they want to "know the rules" and other times when they want to apply a common sense method. I guess the POE does not cover that scenario.
Peace
__________________
Let us get into "Good Trouble." ----------------------------------------------------------- Charles Michael “Mick” Chambers (1947-2010) |
|
|||
Quote:
I guess my first question is how did a sub come into the game during a free throw without any of the crew of 3 noticing it? I always have a hard time justifying a penalty to a player or a team when an entire crew falls asleep (though sometimes a crew has no choice like when they allow 6 players to be in the game for one team and the ball becomes live). In this case, if the free thrower didn't already have the ball, I would just make the kid go back and report in. If the free thrower already had the ball, then it might be a situation where we don't have a choice.
__________________
"To learn, you have to listen. To improve, you have to try." (Thomas Jefferson) Z |
|
|||
Quote:
If the kid goes all the way to the FT line and taps the player he is replacing on the shoulder, then issue a T. If the ball is dead, get it fixed. If the ball is live, issue a T. etc. And, yes, there's judgment involved (what about 2 steps, 3 steps, 4 steps, etc. onto the floor). Deal with it. |
|
|||
Rut, since you are an experienced football official allow me ask you a serious question that relates to this thread.
Would you have called the offside penalty against the player from Louisville on the FG attempt by Rutgers at the end of that game? I hope that you saw the play, but if not here's the gist of it. The player clearly crossed the line of scrimmage prior to the snap of the ball, but he didn't touch anyone, nor did he continue to rush. He stopped and actually backed up as the offense snapped the ball and took the kick, which they missed. Did he affect the play? Last edited by Nevadaref; Tue Nov 14, 2006 at 01:31pm. |
|
|||
Quote:
__________________
M&M's - The Official Candy of the Department of Redundancy Department. (Used with permission.) |
Bookmarks |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
illegal Substitution or illegal Participation | verticalStripes | Football | 11 | Fri Sep 12, 2008 10:57am |
illegal substitution | yankeesfan | Football | 3 | Sun Sep 17, 2006 07:22pm |
Illegal Substitution | whistleman | Volleyball | 8 | Wed Feb 08, 2006 11:43am |
illegal substitution? | yankeesfan | Football | 1 | Tue Aug 30, 2005 06:14am |
Illegal Substitution?? | GPC2 | Football | 6 | Mon Oct 25, 2004 09:37am |