fashion police?

[drinkeii]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

David, are you really delaying the game by not allowing a sub to enter or by sending a player out?

You're trying to kill a mouse with an atomic bomb.

I guess this is why I like the concept of the color cards in soccer - a yellow, being a "formal warning" that makes very clear where you stand, and if you continue, you're out. It doesn't penalize the player or the team in any appreciable way, because they can come back in pretty quickly, and they don't play short. A "T" penalizes the player and the team... seems like there should be something between warnings and T's.

[Junker]

Basketball has formal warnings. There are 4 of them for delay of game. Soccer and basketball are entirely different sports. What works for one will not work for the other. At least I'm assuming so because I now absolutely nothing about soccer. More formal warnings would just lead to more work for the scorer's table and many of them can't handle what they do now.

[drinkeii]

Originally Posted by Junker

Basketball has formal warnings. There are 4 of them for delay of game. Soccer and basketball are entirely different sports. What works for one will not work for the other. At least I'm assuming so because I now absolutely nothing about soccer. More formal warnings would just lead to more work for the scorer's table and many of them can't handle what they do now.

Not quite the same - a formal warning that lets everyone know that you are designating a specific activity or behavior out of bounds for the players or coach. I didn't mean formal in the sense of the "warning for delay", but more formal than "if you do that again, I'm going to T you up" or "that's not appropriate" or "I don't want to see that again" - the card makes sure everyone is clear on the fact that they have been warned.

They are different sports - I don't know about entirely. Both involve attempting to score goals of some kind, both are timed, both have rules and penalties. Basketball and Swimming are totally different. Basketball and track are totally different. Swimming and Track are similar, in the way that Soccer and Basketball are similar. What works for one will not necessarily work for the other, but there are similarities, and some things do apply to both. For example, jewelry rules are the same for both in NFHS - how you deal with jewelry violations differs.

[Junker]

You can do the same thing in basketball. If I warn a coach, it will be clear to anyone watching or near them that they have been warned. I step back, put up one hand giving him or her the stop sign and say firmly, "Coach, that's enough". Now when they complain again and get their T, everyone knew it was coming. That's just the way I was taught to do it.