Did I make the right call on THIS situation?

[dblref]

@refva: Maybe I didn't say it very well, but what I trying to explain is that in a cboa assigned game, you will not see a cboa official and a non-cboa official. Your are right, as an independent contractor, you can work anywhere you choose to work. Not sure exactly what you meant by "tell you what to officiate". Because we use the Arbiter system, and you can "self assign" games, you can (generally) pick & choose any game/time/location you want. That being said, the system was originally set up so that 1st & 2nd year officials could not assign themselves to the more high level games. I was told this was done because most 1st and 2nd year officials did not yet have the skills for that level. This obviously isn't true for everyone.

@ocreferee: I know and have worked with your dad. He is a damn good official and my personal opinion is he should have been moved up earlier that he was. Cardinal has a pretty good training/advancement program. However, like most associations, we have officials that should have advanced quicker and some officials that should not have advanced. I have seen the association ask officials to go back through the summer evaluation program. We used to refer to this as the Flint Hill Program, because of where it was held.

[REFVA]

Not sure exactly what you meant by "tell you what to officiate".

What I meant was, there are some association that don't want you to work for other associations. They think that they have the sole right to your skills. I have hit that block a couple of times. So it is a sensitive topic with most of the officials that I work with. they try not to verbalize where they work.

DBlref, Please turn your private message on. Will discuss further if you like

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by REFVA

What I meant was, there are some association that don't want you to work for other associations. They think that they have the sole right to your skills. I have hit that block a couple of times. So it is a sensitive topic with most of the officials that I work with. they try not to verbalize where they work.

That's how my HS association is. We are not allowed to work leagues/tournament for which our association unsuccessfully made a bid. It's a bullsh*t rule for more reasons than I care to get into in this forum.

We have a HS commissioner and a Rec League commissioner and all assigning is done at their whim. Definitely a touchy subject here on the Peninsula.