![]() |
I disagree with #1. A1 while dribbling bats the ball over B1's head.A1 takes several steps and catches the ball before it hits the floor.Official rules this is a traveling violation.Is the official correct?
I say YES. Rule 9 Section 5.Illegal dribble,or is it 9-4 Travel?. Seems like a violation to me because the ball was batted by team A,then caught in the air after taking steps.If the opponent batted the ball it would be ok. Is "traveling" the correct call or is it another violation?Please point out the correct rule if you can. |
Is 4-15.2 not the case?
Quote:
|
And while we're at it, 4-15.2 not imply that
Quote:
|
Is 4-15.2 the case? I don't think it is because the ball did not touch the floor after the dribbler batted it in the air over B1's head.A1 caught the ball before it hit the floor.
|
I think that implies an illegal dribble, not a travel.
|
Quote:
|
4-15-2 says that a 'bat' does not end the dribble.
Quote:
|
Re: 4-15-2 says that a 'bat' does not end the dribble.
[QUOTE]Originally posted by assignmentmaker
Quote:
|
Re: Re: 4-15-2 says that a 'bat' does not end the dribble.
[QUOTE]Originally posted by WinterWillie
Quote:
2) 4.15.4F, the case to which you refer, includes a bat by the defense. That ends the dribble. 3) A bat by the offense (dribbler) does not end the dribble, *provided the ball is permitted to strike the floor before the ball is touched again with the hands* 4) The emphasized part above didn't happen -- so it was a violation. 5) The official in the play was incorrect in ruling this a travelling violation -- it was a dribbling violation. See 4.15.4D(a) 6) As long as the official blew the whistle, who (other than the IAABO test masters) cares which of the violations he called? |
I'm stuck on #21 A1 receives the ball while straddling the division line.A1 lifts the foot that is in the backcourt,then starts a dribble while hits the division line.When A1 touches the ball after coming back up from the floor,the official rules this a backcourt violation. Is the official correct?
I said NO because I did not think frontcourt status was established until player A had both feet and the ball touching in the frontcourt.I was looking at Rule 9-9 but I am not sure. |
Quote:
|
#33.While A1 is in the act of shooting the first free throw of a one and one,B1 steps into the lane.Official inadvertenly sounds the whistle.A1 continues the motion. The ball enters the basket.Official counts the free throw.Is the official correct?
I checked my index and defenitions for "inadvertent" whistle and could not find anything. I'll say YES,the free throw counts because A1 was in the act of shooting. Can someone please point me to a rule or case play to confirm or correct me? Thanks for the anticipated guidance. |
Larry, check you're e-mail.
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Re: 4-15-2 says that a 'bat' does not end the dribble.
[QUOTE]Originally posted by WinterWillie
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:09am. |