I hate the Fed test..

[cowbyfan1]

From the test. "It is a technical foul whenever bench personnel are standing with the clock is running."

This is true and false as we know there are times when it is not a technical. So what is the fed looking for here? I feel it is false as the question says "whenever" because that would lead to thinking that it is a technical period. Am I reading into this??

[ChuckElias]

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
there are times when it is not a technical.

I think you just answered your own question, Cowboy.

[tjones1]

I agree, Chuck. Cowboy, the reference is 10-4-4.

[JugglingReferee]

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
From the test. "It is a technical foul whenever bench personnel are standing with the clock is running."

Does it really say that?

"...with the clock is running."

Isn't that a grammatical mistake?

[tjones1]

75. A technical foul shall be charged whenever bench personnel are standing while the clock is running.

[M&M Guy]

Originally posted by cowbyfan1
From the test. "It is a technical foul whenever bench personnel are standing with the clock is running."

This is true and false as we know there are times when it is not a technical. So what is the fed looking for here? I feel it is false as the question says "whenever" because that would lead to thinking that it is a technical period. Am I reading into this??

Be careful about posting an exact quote; it may be copyrighted.

Uh, anyway, this is an example of one of the convoluted Fed. questions that manages to confuse many. I would answer false, just because there is a time bench personnel may stand, and that is to react to a good play. If they were to re-word the question to "It is a technical foul every time bench personnel are standing...", then it might make the question a little easier.

[tjones1]

Originally posted by M&M Guy

Be careful about posting an exact quote; it may be copyrighted.

Uh, anyway, this is an example of one of the convoluted Fed. questions that manages to confuse many. I would answer false, just because there is a time bench personnel may stand, and that is to react to a good play. If they were to re-word the question to "It is a technical foul every time bench personnel are standing...", then it might make the question a little easier.

I think they are wanting you to know exception "d".

[Nevadaref]

The reason that question is on there is that an editorial change was made to the coaches' rule this season:

10-4-4 New, 10-5:
A new article was added to 10-4 clarifying when bench personnel may stand. Section 10-5 was reorganized to clarify the head coaches' rule.



The NFHS wants to make sure that everyone got the message. The question is purposely over-inclusive to emphasize that there ARE times when the bench personnel MAY stand.



[Edited by Nevadaref on Oct 11th, 2005 at 02:06 AM]

[cowbyfan1]

That's what I thought. Like I said I was afraid I was reading too much into it.

[w_sohl]

I honestly do not understand why this question was so difficult. It is obviously NOT a T whenever bench personnel stand, only in some cases. I think the question is very simple.