Kick or Fist

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Sure I'd grant it. Not saying that I call it by the letter of the law. As I said, I certainly wouldn't call a kicking violation just because the ball is live. But the ball is live.

I think we're discussing the actual rule here, not practical application. Camron's interp is that the ball is not live until the thrower has it. That's completely contrary to the rule.

Gasp. You'd grant a TO request to one team when the ball is at the disposal of the other team? ()

Btw, I certainly agree with your position on Cameron's interp. Pretty definitive language he's ignoring.