I had THAT play tonight (timer error)

[TravelinMan]

Originally posted by canuckrefguy
Here's how it happened - maybe I didn't include enough detail....

B1 throws, horn goes off, I whistle, ball goes OOB.

I think we did it right....

Canuck, I think, in this sitch, you got the call right.
When you blew your whistle, you whistled play dead BEFORE violation (OOB).

And you should be commended for being alert to blow your whistle in a timely manner.

However, if you, hypothetically didn't blow whistle until after OOB violation occurred, ball should go back to A with 1 second. As far as B players freezing when they heard horn, this does not seem realistic to me. Do shooters freeze when they hear horn? No, they continue shooting even if after horn and are generally oblivious to horn.