The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Mechanics Creep (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/104354-mechanics-creep.html)

SC Official Wed Feb 06, 2019 10:55am

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeremy341a (Post 1029879)
Not disagreeing but why would fists be better? I also seen some saying hand behind the head for player control is a weak signal. I don't understand that either.

Fists on hips is much stronger and less awkward than open hands. There's a reason you don't see very many officials using open hands unless they work in/for a micro-managing assigner/state.

#olderthanilook Wed Feb 06, 2019 11:08am

Quote:

Originally Posted by SC Official (Post 1029868)
Kansas Ref, do you give a preliminary on every foul you call and verbally inform the fouler? Aren't those things in the manual?

Based on the times I've seen Kansas officials work, he probably does most, if not all, of the time.

Freddy Wed Feb 06, 2019 11:18am

Hi, I'm Freddy, and I'm . . .
 
I'm no doubt the exception here. And I'm good with that.
I'm one of those who, by virtue of the position to which I've been appointed, teach and maintain prescribed and approved mechanics -- and signals -- as dictated by the ruling body of the code that prevails over those whose training I'm responsible for. And I'm good with that.
I understand that the preferences and interests of others in other areas and even of assigners and AD's and coaches -- and even some officials -- in our area here may differ. And I'm good with that.
I have learned that intelligent officials can pursue excellence in play-calling while at the same time prioritize using prescribed mechanics and approved signals asked of them. And I'm good with that.

jeremy341a Wed Feb 06, 2019 11:31am

Quote:

Originally Posted by SC Official (Post 1029881)
Fists on hips is much stronger and less awkward than open hands. There's a reason you don't see very many officials using open hands unless they work in/for a micro-managing assigner/state.

Do you feel that the fists mechanic makes it more likely the call will be perceived as correct or do you feel it makes the official seem more confident in their call?

SC Official Wed Feb 06, 2019 11:40am

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeremy341a (Post 1029886)
Do you feel that the fists mechanic makes it more likely the call will be perceived as correct or do you feel it makes the official seem more confident in their call?

Both. Perception is a big deal. I can give off a more confident perception with fists than open hands.

I've never seen an official give an open hand preliminary block signal that looks good. I want to be strong in all my mechanics, irrespective of whether a call needs "sold" or not.

BillyMac Wed Feb 06, 2019 11:48am

Poor Mechanics ...
 
For thirty-seven of the past thirty-eight years I've worked with, and observed, an outstanding official. He could call the hell out of a game, manage the heck out of a game, and charm the pants off of any coach, player, fan, or partner. In his heyday, he was a state tournament official, and a college official. When he walked into a gym, everybody greeted him like he was the mayor. Even in his later years he could run rings around younger partners.

He ended his season every year by volunteering to officiate Special Olympics Unified Games, most of us volunteer at one site, he would volunteer for several sites.

His mechanics were far from perfect. Sometimes he made up signals (some quite funny looking) on the spot, and sometimes his rotations and switches weren't quite kosher (once spotted him doing a 540 degree switch, he just kept moving until he felt comfortable).

Everybody wanted to work with this guy, coaches wanted this guy in their games.

I learned a lot from him, not about mechanics, but about everything else regarding officiating basketball games.

After fifty years on the court, he retired last season. I miss him. He was a great partner. He was fun to work with. He was fun to watch.

I know that a lot of us, including me, take officiating very seriously, but it is, after all, a game, and we should be allowed to have a little fun, not a lot, but a little.

But his great official/poor mechanics was an anomaly, an outlier. Here on my local board, he was the exception, not the rule.

onetime1 Wed Feb 06, 2019 12:40pm

I call my block foul with closed fists and hit my hips about 7 or 8 times and do it simultaneously while hopping toward the score table. I do this because I think Joey Crawford looks really cool doing it.

SNIPERBBB Wed Feb 06, 2019 02:45pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by onetime1 (Post 1029893)
I call my block foul with closed fists and hit my hips about 7 or 8 times and do it simultaneously while hopping toward the score table. I do this because I think Joey Crawford looks really cool doing it.

That's basically what OHSAA doesn't want to see.

Freddy Wed Feb 06, 2019 04:09pm

The approved signal I teach here:
Block - Good Call, Good Signal, Good Report

deecee Wed Feb 06, 2019 05:24pm

If someone that has sway on your schedule says something to you, make an adjustment. Otherwise no one cares. I am yet to have an assignor go to me "hey the block signal is open palm, inner hand to waist. Not this closed fist nonsense." I've worked for about half a dozen in 15 years.

JRutledge Wed Feb 06, 2019 06:33pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by deecee (Post 1029905)
If someone that has sway on your schedule says something to you, make an adjustment. Otherwise no one cares. I am yet to have an assignor go to me "hey the block signal is open palm, inner hand to waist. Not this closed fist nonsense." I've worked for about half a dozen in 15 years.

I know I have worked for 30 or so different people in basketball alone and never had any of them complain about my mechanics in this way.

Peace

Stat-Man Wed Feb 06, 2019 08:36pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paintguru (Post 1029862)
I'm more worried about both referees on a 2-person game being on the same side of the court multiple times, as I saw last night.

Both the 2017-19 NFHS Officials Manual, 2 Person Crew Item 4.3.3 and the MHSAA-specific Mechanics Manual spell out instances where the lead may go ballside to cover a match-up.

I can't speak for whether this action was proper in the game you observed, but I wanted to point out that this is a mechanic in certain situations.

Rich Wed Feb 06, 2019 09:02pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paintguru (Post 1029862)
I'm pretty sure I do all four to some degree. Signals are meant to communicate information. IMO, as long as that information is being communicated, most should be fine with it. Obviously there are mechanic sticklers out there, but as others have said, I'm not sure why anyone should care unless it impacts the actual game in some way.

I'm more worried about both referees on a 2-person game being on the same side of the court multiple times, as I saw last night.


I assime you're not talking about going ballside here - if you are, I would be concerned with a crew whose lead never went ballside.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

ODog Wed Feb 06, 2019 11:18pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 1029900)
The approved signal I teach here:
Block - Good Call, Good Signal, Good Report

Freddy, I'm glad you have a sense of humor.

That is seriously the most embarrassing thing I've seen, especially since his partner (whose call it was) was correctly about to call a PC foul.

That is unbelievable. And it sure looks like a varsity (2-whistle?!) game in California. Whoa ...

AremRed Thu Feb 07, 2019 12:07am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 1029900)
The approved signal I teach here:
Block - Good Call, Good Signal, Good Report

That's the best sell of a call I've ever seen. In any sport. At any level. That guy is God-tier.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:33pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1