Three officials who aren't advancing

[bucky]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

1. The whistle was for a foul by a defender against the shooter.
2. What is the status of the ball after any made goal?

Save

1. Yea, I know, as indicated.

2. When was the goal made?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by bucky

Is that a dead ball T or a live ball T?

Does it make a difference?

Originally Posted by bucky

1. Yea, I know, as indicated.

2. When was the goal made?

When the conditions were met.

(Similar to a violation happening "at the same time" as a foul, the officials must decide which happened first.)

[bucky]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Does it make a difference?



When the conditions were met.

(Similar to a violation happening "at the same time" as a foul, the officials must decide which happened first.)

Yes, it does. When were the conditions met?

With all due respect Bob, don't be like that. Don't be like so many others that do not provide actual answers.

side note: I wonder how officials would have reacted if there was no whistle for the foul. I also wonder what the clock operator would have done if there was less than a minute in the game and there was no whistle. (presuming, like NCAAM, clock stops under a min for NCCAW)

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by bucky

Yes, it does. When were the conditions met?

With all due respect Bob, don't be like that. Don't be like so many others that do not provide actual answers.

side note: I wonder how officials would have reacted if there was no whistle for the foul. I also wonder what the clock operator would have done if there was less than a minute in the game and there was no whistle. (presuming, like NCAAM, clock stops under a min for NCCAW)

If there was a technical foul called why would it matter if the ball was dead or live?

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by bucky

Y
With all due respect Bob, don't be like that. Don't be like so many others that do not provide actual answers.

I gave an actual answer -- and, the correct one.

And, it should be "who." Another actual answer.

[bucky]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

I gave an actual answer -- and, the correct one.

And, it should be "who." Another actual answer.

Thanks for the grammar correction. I do appreciate that although when you indicated "Does it make a difference?", I consider that to be a question, not an answer. Perhaps you were thinking that your question was providing an answer but if we are sticking to strict grammar rules.. suddenly, then it did not. Furthermore, "When the conditions were met" is not even a complete sentence and does not answer the question but rather repeats it in a different form.

Coach: Why was my player given a technical foul?
You: The conditions were met

I am not confident that you would answer that way.

The bigger picture is exactly what you described by saying "When the conditions are met." Give rule book citations that apply to when the ball is stuck in the net as to its status and those conditions please.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by bucky

Thanks for the grammar correction. I do appreciate that although when you indicated "Does it make a difference?", I consider that to be a question, not an answer. Perhaps you were thinking that your question was providing an answer but if we are sticking to strict grammar rules.. suddenly, then it did not. Furthermore, "When the conditions were met" is not even a complete sentence and does not answer the question but rather repeats it in a different form.

Coach: Why was my player given a technical foul?
You: The conditions were met

I am not confident that you would answer that way.

The bigger picture is exactly what you described by saying "When the conditions are met." Give rule book citations that apply to when the ball is stuck in the net as to its status and those conditions please.

okay --

Yes, it would have been a dead ball T or a live ball T. I am still not sure it makes a difference to any subsequent administration -- that's why I asked a serious question.

And, the parenthetical part of my initial response is (or implies to any intelligent reader) the answer to your second question -- the ball becomes dead when the official decides the ball is stuck in the net.

[LRZ]

Bucky, I think bob is trying to teach you to fish.