Backcourt Violation

[MelbRef]

I talked with a fairly knowledgeable official recently who said this situation is a backcourt violation.

His assertion seems to violate my criteria of 1)Team Control, 2)Last to Touch/First to Touch

I wonder if there is some technicality that I'm missing...

- A1 inbounds the ball from their frontcourt endline.
- The inbound pass deflects off of A2 while in the front-court, and rolls into the backcourt.
- A3 retrieves the ball in the backcourt.

His ruling, "Backcourt Violation"

He says that if A2 retrieves the ball, rather than A3, it is not a backcourt violation.

Am I missing something? I don't see that Team Control in the front court has been established.

[just another ref]

First, he's wrong about the play. Second, which A player recovers the ball never is a factor in whether or not you have a backcourt violation.

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by just another ref

First, he's wrong about the play. Second, which A player recovers the ball never is a factor in whether or not you have a backcourt violation.

I second this, assuming we're talking about NCAA or NFHS.

NBA has some quirks to rule depending on time of game and other stuff I'm not too familiar with.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Mregor]

Originally Posted by MelbRef

I talked with a fairly knowledgeable official recently who said this situation is a backcourt violation.

I wonder if there is some technicality that I'm missing...

- A1 inbounds the ball from their frontcourt endline.
- The inbound pass deflects off of A2 while in the front-court, and rolls into the backcourt.
- A3 retrieves the ball in the backcourt.

His ruling, "Backcourt Violation"

Am I missing something?

You are missing nothing. Your friend is wrong.

[Nevadaref]

Is he a FIBA ref?

[MelbRef]

No, he's a NFHS ref.

Thanks guys...

[BillyMac]

The four elements for having a backcourt violation are: there must be team control (and initial player control
when coming from a throw-in); the ball must have achieved frontcourt status; the team in team control must
be the last to touch the ball before it goes into the backcourt; that same team must be the first to touch after
the ball has been in the backcourt.

[Adam]

He's confusing concepts. The exception that allows a player to catch a throw-in pass doesn't apply to anyone but the first player to touch the ball, but that doesn't apply to any other situation on the throw-in.

He's also getting that concept incorrect, but that's a different thread for your next conversation with him. I'd question whether he's "knowledgeable" about the rules. He may well be a great official, but his rules knowledge is suspect.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by MelbRef

I talked with a fairly knowledgeable official recently who said this situation is a backcourt violation.

His assertion seems to violate my criteria of 1)Team Control, 2)Last to Touch/First to Touch

I wonder if there is some technicality that I'm missing...

- A1 inbounds the ball from their frontcourt endline.
- The inbound pass deflects off of A2 while in the front-court, and rolls into the backcourt.
- A3 retrieves the ball in the backcourt.

His ruling, "Backcourt Violation"

He says that if A2 retrieves the ball, rather than A3, it is not a backcourt violation.

Am I missing something? I don't see that Team Control in the front court has been established.

Any conversation that includes one team member being allowed to retrieve the ball, but not another team member, is not a knowledge-based conversation.